Movies Totally Different From the Books They Were Based On

Ring of Bright Water

In the movie: Graham Merrill is wandering the streets of London, when he happens to pass by a pet shop selling an adorably charming otter. Merrill adopts the little critter, names him Mij, and brings him back to his apartment. Soon enough, he realizes that an apartment is not an ideal home for an otter, so he and Mij move to a cottage in the middle of nowhere on the west coast of Scotland. Merrill begins to fall in love with a local doctor, as Mij keeps up his delightful hijinks throughout the film, which has a shocking ending that we won’t ruin for you here.

In the book: The writer moves to the middle of nowhere in Scotland on his own and describes the beauty of his natural surroundings in so much depth that the otter doesn’t appear until halfway through the book. Did we say “otter”? We meant to say “otters.” That’s right, there are more than a few of the cute critters, many of which get lost or die throughout the book. Oh, and the romance with the doctor? That never comes up in the book.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] Pe final, un top: 9 filme total diferite de cărțile pe care sunt bazate. [...]

[...] final, un top: 9 filme total diferite de cărțile pe care sunt bazate. Nici un [...]

How could you not mention "the Natural"? Also one I just read and saw is The Dark Fields which was made into the movie Limitless.

I'd also include the trilogy of movies based on David Peace's Red Riding Quartet (broadcast on Channel Four, and released theatrically). I was absolutely shocked how profoundly the screenwriter had changed these great novels. The ending's the greatest shock of all: if you haven't read the novels, imagine exactly the opposite of what happens in the last film, and you've got the absolutely brutal end of the last book.

Don't you think you should mention the authors of the books involved? In several cases you didn't.

Disney is pretty notorious for this sort of thing, but Hunchback of Notre Dame is particularly egregious in that they subverted the original message about superficiality and beauty only being skin deep explored in the characters of Esmeralda and Phoebus in order to turn the pretty people into the heroes. Terrible.

you totally missed "forrest gump"!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] final, un top: 9 filme total diferite de cărțile pe care sunt bazate. Nici un [...]

  2. [...] Pe final, un top: 9 filme total diferite de cărțile pe care sunt bazate. [...]