Leann Hunley, Dawson’s Creek’s Tamara Jacobs
She wasn’t a constant presence like Mr. Feeny, but who could forget Leann Hunley’s foxy Tamara Jacobs, the English teacher who took Pacey Witter’s virginity? Ms. Jacobs skipped town when word of her and Pacey’s affair got out, but Hunley hasn’t done a similar disappearing act. Along with a few TV guest appearances over the years (remember her as Shira Huntzberger on Gilmore Girls?), she returned to a gig she began long before her time in Capeside: Days of Our Lives. Over 20 years after leaving the soap opera, Hunley resumed the role of Anna DiMera in 2007.