Kate and Tom’s time capsule: Sentimental Lostie
Sawyer’s letter: Vengeful Lostie
Charlie’s Drive Shaft gear: Rocker Lostie
Survival tools and bottled water: Practical Lostie
Virgin Mary statues: Religious and/or heroin-addicted Lostie
Season 2
Mr. Cluck costume: Lostie with a sense of humor
Shannon’s death outfit: Lostie with a sick sense of humor
Sayid’s torture tools: Sick Lostie (sense of humor optional)
Sawyer’s novels: Bookworm Lostie
Swan station record player and LPs: Retro Lostie
Season 3
Claire’s dress: Stylish Lostie
Dharma beer cans: Lostie who watched the show drunk
Locke’s flash-forward coffin: Morbid Lostie
Ben’s tribal masks: Anthropologist Lostie
Penny’s engagement ring: Romantic Lostie
Season 4
Photo of Jack and Aaron: Pro-Jack and Kate Lostie
Ben’s traveling gear: Worldly Lostie
Faraday’s time machine and rat maze: Physics geek Lostie
Miles’s ghost detector: Ouija board-toting Lostie
Jacob’s cabin blueprint: Die-hard Team Jacob Lostie
Season 5
Kate’s ’70s Dharma outfit: Bohemian Lostie
Sun’s wedding outfits: Engaged Lostie
Hurley’s Empire Strikes Back rewrite: Star Wars geek Lostie
Prop nuke: Destructive Lostie
The Dharma van: Stoner Lostie
Season 6
Ben’s “Dr. Linus” costume: Academic Lostie
Temple fragment: Lostie who can (and will!) read hieroglyphics
Dogen and Lennon’s costumes: Lostie interested in Lost cosplay
Claire’s squirrel baby: Hysterical Lostie
Jacob and the Man in Black’s game: Metaphysical Lostie