10 Contemporary Books That Challenged White, Male Literary Dominance

Last week, we published a list of 10 essential books of the past 25 years. It was one of our most popular posts of all time, as well as one of our most contentious, racking up over 100 comments. Much of the argument has focused on the list’s lack of diversity: of the 10 books, eight were written by white men.

Since best-of lists can’t help but be subjective and flawed, and because there have been so many game-changing books by women and people of color in the past 25 years, we’ve put together an alternate top 10 list. Don’t think of it as an affirmative action move or a consolation prize, but rather as proof that you could make an equally strong list of the past few decades’ greatest literary achievements without including a single American- or British-born white guy. The highbrow novels, page-turning bestsellers, and one particularly inspired graphic novel after the jump all challenged the received wisdom that literature is or should be dominated by white dudes.

Toni Morrison, Beloved (1987)

Toni Morrison has spent the past four decades writing challenging and insightful novels featuring black characters. Among the most powerful of these is Beloved, about a slave woman named Sethe and her daughter Denver, who live and work on a plantation in the wake of their failed escape from slavery, and are haunted by the ghost of a baby known only as Beloved. Morrison was inspired by the real-life story of the escaped slave Margaret Garner, who killed her daughter because she couldn’t bear to see her return to the plantation. Beloved won the Pulitzer Prize in 1988, and ten years later, Jonathan Demme directed a film adaptation, which famously starred (and was produced by) Oprah. It’s also won a spot on English syllabi in high schools and colleges around the country.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] Flavorpill gives us 10 contemporary novels that challenge white male dominance. [...]

[...] Flavorwire » 10 Contemporary Books That Challenged White, Male ... Well then, define contemporary ? Yes ? No? May be? How can contemporary make up for omissions in 'essential books of past 25 years' ? And, is it past or last 25 years, especially when we are measuring against the adjective . [...]

[...] from Flavorwire.com, an apology of sorts: Last week, we published a list of 10 essential books of the past 25 years. It was one of our most po... [...]

[...] Flavorwire » 10 Contemporary Books That Challenged White, Male … [...]

[...] å produsere barn. Tjenerinnens beretning er  listet flere ganger, blant annet nylig av Flavorwire 10 samtidsromaner som utfordrer den hvite manns litterære dominans (forøvrig en diskutabel [...]

The Known Road, written by a black male former accountant (he spent, like, 20 years working on it) is pretty good, especially for contemporary literature. You have to love a black guy that takes on the issue of BLACKS OWNING BLACK SLAVES in the South and elsewhere, especially since this still goes on in Haiti and Africa. The book is touching, really, and really sets the scene for what life was like then. It gets a little slow in the middle. Apparently, these "free blacks" owned slaves at higher rates than whites (10% of them, compared with 4% of southern whites, and 1% of all americans at the time). Of course, the overwhelming majority of us "whites" are descended from people who immigrated here after slavery... it's quite a sham to potray contemporary America as nation of descendents of slaves and slave-owners. That was never true. Less true today.

The fact that "white males" apparently invented about 90% of the things that comprise the modern world will not stop me from trying to invent things, write books, etc. As a woman, I strive to live up to the best of my abilities, to my potential... not compete with other "groups" or disparage them and resent them. Women are different than men. I'm not obsessed with "equal outcomes".

I'd add Maxine Hong Kingston's book (read it as a kid, forgot the name) and perhaps Gabriel Garcia Marquez's Love in the Time of Cholera. Richard Wright's short stories are good. BUT WHAT'S SO BAD ABOUT "WHITE MALES"? And why apologize when America is still 70% "white"? 8/10 books you chose were written by white males... about America's demographics... European cultures tend to prize literature more than other groups... Sub-saharan Africa did not have a written language before the white colonizers came in. So why apologize? Should I apologize to "asian-americans" that the contents of my ipod are about half white, half black artists? Blacks are way over-represented on my ipod... mostly jazz and classic stuff (rock, soul, blues, etc). I go with what I like. Should East Indians apologize for the fact that they now comprise 40% of American medical doctors? No surprise, they are now THE wealthiest "group" in America, despite thier brown skin, and the constant drumbeat of what a racist society America is. Should American Jews apologize for their astounding success? Should Asians apologize for being way over-represented (as the Jews were/are) in America's most prestigious universities? Should Caribbean and African blacks apologize for generally out-performing (by every measure) American blacks? Signed, Half Jewish "white" woman, Writer, who doesn't care that "white males" and males in general earn more money on average, etc, etc. PS... are the Jews "white" these days?

Uh... Bolaño is white --- of Spanish decent. Speaking Spanish does not make you not-white.

I'm sorry, but Sethe lived on her own free-holding small farm, representing the dream of home/land ownership for freedpeople. She most decidedly did NOT live on a plantation. And it wasn't a failed escape from slavery. She got away. She gave up to get away--and that's an important part of the story--but she definitely got away.

I'm surprised both Salman Rushdie AND John Coetzee are excluded from this list. Given the fact that both wrote in a postcolonial set up, I think their works deserved a mention. And what about Gabriel Garcia Marquez? Apart from that, I enjoyed seeing Toni Morrison on the list, as she is one of my favourite African American writers.

Margaret Atwood, Oryx and Crake

I find this offensive that y'all decided to post this list simply because people were pissed off at the other one, which I defended btw. You either revise the old list to include more minorities - although a work should be judged on its own merit (which means perhaps Fight Club is not the way you want to go) - or you do nothing. This is just a cheap attempt at reconciliation designed either to piss off white men or placate all others. When are we going to get beyond race and gender, people? Get your mind right. p.s. I still love these lists, keep 'em coming, just don't differentiate on the basis of ethnicity/sexuality/gender/or any other nonsense!

how could you miss chinua achebe and harumki murakami?

No mention of anything by IRIS MURDOCH? One of the greatest novelists of the 20th Century?

I'm wondering where you guys are seeing words like "best" or "only" or "definitive" on these lists. Also interested in why you're inclined to treat two different authors as exactly the same person, just because we've written for the same publication. Considering that you profess to be academics, I worry about your close-reading skills.

I agree with Lit Prof. Anybody who has ever spent any time in a university literature class has been trained -- or should have been trained -- to examine their own bias. And if you didn't notice your bias when you compiled the first list, which was so clearly the kind of books enjoyed by young white men, you're not looking deeply enough at your choices. Not that there's anything wrong with being a young white man who enjoys books like "Fight Club." But there is something wrong with thinking that the books you and your friends like are the "essential" books without ever noticing that you'd missed out on the dominant trend of contemporary (21st century) literature written in English -- new voices writing about the immigrant experience. This list compounds the first problem by a)having no governing principal and b)indicating that the last time the authors read a book by a woman was sometime around 1990.

grumble grumble grumble!

People need to relax. Make your own list and post it if you're so offended. The lists haven't been titled "The Only Correct Lists of Books EVER and if You Don't Agree You're Wrong and Should Be Fired from Whatever Stupid Job You Have!"

And what about Things Fall Apart? And Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man? Sorry, sorry lack of African and African American writers on this list, missing real classics.

I don't see the relevance of some of these books. No matter how the authors' ethnic origin, identity or gender may justify their inclusion in such a list, I don't really understand how these books are a departure from a cultural milieu that has white males as their dominant elements. I mean, The Kite Runner is a sentimental, conventional novel. Just as The God of Small Things is no piece of avantgarde fiction or Bolano's 2666, as wild as it gets, not far from 'white' postmodern experiments. They don't break with tradition and they don't seem to be the sort of fiction that deal with their peculiar condition. They're not Marguerite Duras, Sam Selvon, or even Zadie Smith for that matter.

What about Octavia Butler? Black woman writing SciFi!

I would have to agree with lit prof. Your staff should be embarrassed for bungling both of these lists. These types of lists will always draw critics who are angered by specific omissions. But, to make a white male list and then the list “that challenged white male literary dominance” exposes exactly how marginally literate and provincial your staff truly is. (A fraudulent book by James Frey is “essential”? Seriously?) Congrats, you have proven yourselves to be a waste of time. Fire your entire staff and start over.

The Kitchen God's Wife, Amy Tan. Antelope Wife, Louise Erdrich. Poisonwood Bible, Barbara Kingsolver. Omeros, Derek Walcott. Evidence of Things Unseen, Marianne Wiggins. Sea of Poppies, Amitov Ghosh. Half a Yellow Sun, Chamamanda Ngozi Adichie. The Known World, Edward P. Jones. The News from Paraguay, Lucy Tuck. Feast of the Goat, Mario Vargas Llosa.

"essentialist" v. "minority." cute. it's so . . . first-year. flavorwire should really consider avoiding literature and bookstores.

Bolano should have been on the main list. So should have Murakami. and Didion.

@Ryan-I think colonialism, postcolonialism, class infrastructure in Chile and Mexico, racial hierarchical structures, and perceptions of race concerning Latinos, who are frequently not categorized or seen as European, should be enough to place Bolano on the list.

Bolano should not be on this list, since he is a white male of European descent, as many Latinos are.

Well then, define contemporary. 1985-2010? Yes ? No? May be? How can contemporary make up for omissions in 'essential books of past 25 years' ? And, is it past or last 25 years, especially when we are measuring against the adjective 'contemporary'? So that's essentially left us with 10 + 10 + 9 (29) books essential ? contemporary? books of the last / past 25 years. Not to forget significant omissions of Mark Z. Danielewski, Ishiguro, Murakami, Robinson, and Coupland. Would have been good enough just to say - check out the good, acclaimed books published in the last 30 years ( if not by anything at least by library check out rates) without making another pointless list!!

What, no Sherman Alexie?!

I would have appreciated not knowing everything about Never Let Me Go. I just bought it yesterday and was planning on reading it blind. Thanks :/

This list is sad. I understand the motivation for making it. But it neglects female writers from America who are white. Further more, it neglects female writers from America who are white and write short stories, among whom are some of American's best writers.

Honestly I knew the plot of Never Let Me Go when I read it and it is still probably my favorite book of all time, literally. But spoiler alert would be nice. But seriously, it is just a masterpiece. Just thinking about it waters my eyes. And the last section SPOILER ALERT!!! about her memories washing ashore is one of the most beautiful passages ever written.

A few of my favorite authors are on this list. But... I miss Murakami!

No Battle Royale? Really? :O

You really have a responsibility to put a SPOILER ALERT on the Never Let Me Go slide before you give away its secrets, which you've done here.d

Oh, lists. Are bigger. Bigger than you. And you are not me. The lengths that I will go to.

A lot of the movie reviews tried to skirt the surprise. Not like it's not apparent within the first couple of chapters, but it's one of those books where you feel some satisfaction as you figure out the narrator's world before she does.

I assumed that everyone who had read a movie review in the past year already knew...

Not that I think anyone hasn't figured it out by now... but it's much better to read Never Let Me Go without knowing the big picture. So, um, spoiler alert?

Trackbacks

  1. Books says:

    [...] Flavorwire » 10 Contemporary Books That Challenged White, Male … [...]

  2. [...] from Flavorwire.com, an apology of sorts: Last week, we published a list of 10 essential books of the past 25 years. It was one of our most po… [...]

  3. [...] Flavorwire » 10 Contemporary Books That Challenged White, Male … Well then, define contemporary ? Yes ? No? May be? How can contemporary make up for omissions in 'essential books of past 25 years' ? And, is it past or last 25 years, especially when we are measuring against the adjective . [...]

  4. [...] å produsere barn. Tjenerinnens beretning er  listet flere ganger, blant annet nylig av Flavorwire 10 samtidsromaner som utfordrer den hvite manns litterære dominans (forøvrig en diskutabel [...]

  5. [...] Flavorpill gives us 10 contemporary novels that challenge white male dominance. [...]