Mixtape Primer: Essential and Under-Rated Cover Versions

For an art form that so mythologizes rebellion, rock ‘n roll has developed its fair share of orthodoxy over the years. If you go with the canon, Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band is the best album ever, while cover versions started and ended with Jimi Hendrix’s take on “All Along The Watchtower.” Happily, Flavorpill doesn’t really buy into any of that. With a (god-awful) cover of Biffy Clyro’s “Many of Horror” taking the coveted Christmas No. 1 slot across the Atlantic, it seems an auspicious time to look back at some unsung excellent cover versions. Listen to them all after the jump — and for convenience, we’ve also embedded a Grooveshark playlist of the whole lot at the end.

SIDE ONE

1. John Cale – “All My Friends” (7:38)
Originally by LCD Soundsystem

Remarkably, Cale somehow manages to make LCD Soundsystem’s already masterful portrait of middle-aged party fatigue and alienation even better, investing it with a relentless motorik beat and ever more manic vocals that still manage to convey real emotional depth.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] amused ourselves over the quiet period between Christmas and New Year’s Eve by compiling a mixtape of the best cover versions ever. Hearing about Mastodon’s hugely unlikely cover of Feist’s “A Commotion” [...]

What is this Site ??? Why have you got my Videos on here ?? Don't you think you should ask for my permission first ???

Ane Brun did PJ Harvey's the Dancer as well as a great Big in Japan cover. Also I feel I have to mention Jeff Buckley doing Leonhard Cohen's "hallelujah". Just have to.

what no Wax Audio Imagine This !!!!

Tori Amos did a great cover of Eminem's '97 Bonnie and Clyde--totally turned it on its head.

The Sonic Youth version is great but I find Paul Quinn's version on Alan Horne Postcard records much more haunting: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cevlfjm7PP8

How about Willie De Ville's cover of Jimi Hendrix's "Hey Joe"?

(Sorry - didn't mean to sound snotty with the "actually", there.)

Cave's ex-girlfriend (Anita Lane, actually) did a fantastic cover of Chic's "Lost in Music", with some Bad Seeds backing, and Cave doing backing vocals. (And, not to be ignored, the Fall's cover of "Lost in Music" is oddly fantastic.) Cave has done many great covers himself, but for my money, his best is "By the Time I Get to Phoenix". AND, since we mentioned Chic, the best Chic cover is Robert Wyatt's mournful "At Last I Am Free".

Bat for Lashes' cover of The Boss' "I'm on Fire" is pretty darn good too -- lush and sexually fraught in a female way.

This might qualify as too well-known and obvious -- but the Cowboy Junkies' "Sweet Jane" ruined the original for me.

Superchunk's version of Stephin Merritt's "100,000 Fireflies"

A great list of covers that have been done well. There are alot of bad ones out there

Jon - wow! That's amazing... Would love to have seen them, but alas they were a little bit before my time (and as far as I'm aware they never came to Australia anyway). I did see Dean & Britta playing Galaxie 500 songs recently, and I met them last year – they were lovely. And I'll check out the Eurythmics cover too - thanks for the tip!

Eurythmics cover of Lou Reed's "Satellite of Love" was originally released only on a promotional cassette in 1983 but later on a remaster CD of the full "Sweet Dreams" album. It's pretty majestic, and even Reed gave it a knod way back when. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EpK0sc4B66Q

The Galaxie 500 show that this clip is from is The Point in Atlanta; they'd just driven in apparently. I was sitting on the floor during their set as were others cos it was so heavy....amongst other things. But met them after to sign LPs; they were nice.

Hey, just catching up on comments. Zoe - wow, I'll check that out! Mark - :) Bob Lukomski - rocking pun there, Bob. Hey 19 - Blink-182 was indeed a joke. Justin - I figured that one was pretty well-known. RCATL - yep, that's a good 'un. Summer - Nick certainly does a mean cover. His version of 'Fairytale of New York' is also good, and the Bad Seeds did a great version of 'In the Ghetto' many years ago.

Nick Cave covering Neil Young's Helpless on the Bridge compilation. Stunning.

What About Peaches covers of ZZ Top?

Where's Johnny Cash's version of NIN's "Hurt"?

Ok Blink 182 was a joke, but if you are going to pick a Mountain Goats Cover, it has to be "Ignition:remix". Any Yelloman cover, also.

Blink 182 covering Lit's "My Own Worst Enemy" - Discuss

Sorry, but this is one of the low points for G500. For an amazingly retarded band that was amazing, this is just retarded. Turns a good bass riff into a boring 5-1 change, over and over and over. The Spaceman ref only shows how far G500 were from being that lunar. Instead Dean settled for Luna.

Great picks! Though The Mountain Goats' version of Ace of Base's "The Sign" is really something to behold: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sONMDqGGv78

Trackbacks

  1. [...] amused ourselves over the quiet period between Christmas and New Year’s Eve by compiling a mixtape of the best cover versions ever. Hearing about Mastodon’s hugely unlikely cover of Feist’s “A Commotion” [...]