33 Women Music Critics You Need to Read

Ideally, you wouldn’t need a list like this, which might sound as patronizing as a “women in rock” magazine issue, but like most other professions, music journalism is still mostly a sausage fest. Think of about it. Who’s the most revered saint in the biz? Lester Bangs. Who are the elder statesmen? Greil Marcus, Robert Christgau, Richard Meltzer. The recent “voice of a generation”? Chuck Klosterman. Sure, we admire ‘em but do you notice a pattern here?

A sea change may be happening, though. This month saw the publication of Out of the Vinyl Deeps, an anthology of music writing the late New Yorker critic Ellen Willis. The book also contained tributes to Willis from other women music writers, and resulted in a conference celebrating Willis (and featuring some of the field’s brightest stars) at NYU. Also this year, the Village Voice finally named a woman to head up their music section, for the first time in years, NPR’s online music section now features a woman in a major post. And that’s only the tip of the iceberg. So, this seems like a good time to toast some of the most noteworthy women in the field.

Though we salute a good number of writers here, this list is obviously incomplete. There are great writers who are no longer with us (Penny Valentine), who aren’t writing about music now (Barbara Flaska, Stacy McArdle), who write occasionally now (Carla DeSantis, Carola Dibbell, Deborah Frost, Amy Schroeder), who currently cover other parts of the pop spectrum (Kathy Fennessy, Joy Press, Tricia Romano) or whose current music scribing status is unclear (Gerri Hirshey, Mim Udovitch).

And in the end, there are actually hundreds of women music journalists that you should be reading. But this is a start.

Stacey Anderson

Though her background includes writing for NBC-New York and Spin, Anderson’s rightfully best known for her current going-on-three-years stint as Senior Associate Editor at the Village Voice, which also includes the sometimes-thankless-but-vital job as listings editor, not to mention brilliant pieces like her peek into Woody Allen’s music career, including a rare interview with the recluse himself. In addition, she helms the weekly “This Week In Rock History” column for Rolling Stone, and even her brief Voice previews for are informative and fun.

Daphne Brooks

Though she holds the prestigious post as a Princeton professor, specializing in African-American literature and teaching courses such as “Like a Rolling Stone: Race, Gender, Rock Music Criticism & Popular Music Culture,” Brooks also has an impressive scribing career — an article for The Nation on Beyoncé, a 33 1/3 series book on Jeff Buckley, an essay on the politics and comedy of legendary dancer/singer Josephine Baker, and an upcoming treatise on women in R&B. We just wanna know why our college profs couldn’t have been as cool as Brooks.

Daphne Carr

Former zine editor and current member of Columbia University’s ethnomusicology program, Carr made a splash in Gotham, becoming Da Capo’s Series Editor of the Best Music Writing books for the last several years as well as serving as editor for Columbia’s Current Musicology journal. In addition, she recently wrote a book on Nine Inch Nails’ Pretty Hate Machine for 33 1/3 and penned one of the afterwards for the Willis anthology. Carr also co-founded (along with the writer of this article) and administers “girlgroup,” a discussion forum for women music journalists (including many listed here). Also check out her website , which includes her blog, playlists, activities, and photography.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] Further Exploration: 33 Women Music Critics You Need to Read – I’m taking [...]

[...] Here’s the list… [...]

[...] VIEW ARTICLE SOURCE [...]

[...] Gross lists 33 female music critics whose work you should be reading. (At [...]

[...] a more thorough job, and includes many of the books on my own list (and one I hated). Their list of 33 female music critics you need to read is also pretty [...]

Kudos for giving a nod to Penny Valentine as a great writer who is no longer with us. But, two writers who should have been mentioned in the same context in those opening paragraphs are Lillian Roxon and Gloria Stavers.

So many talented women on this list! I must say, Jeanne Fury is my personal favorite. She knows her stuff and always gets a chuckle out of me.

Thirty-six women mentioned, and no love for Ms. Caryn Ganz? Of Rolling Stone, Spin, etc.?

Three more people (among many) I should have included too: * Maria Tessa Sciarrino - great blogger, see http://herjazz.org * Kristine McKenna - author of "Talk To Her" and some great liner notes * Judy Berman- here at Flavorpill, who works really hard and deserves more credit!

Farah Jasmine Griffin. Also have to agree that Michelle Mercer has been overlooked. She doesn't contribute regularly to magazines anymore, but her books more than qualify her for this list.

You failed to mention Lois Wilson, who writes about funk and soul (and other things) for Mojo and has written loads of sleeve notes, etc.

Fine article, but you should be crediting photos. I know I took that photo of Ann Powers, so I'm guessing that none of the other photos are your work either, and they should be credited to the respective photographers.

I have noticed Phares name for quite some time as she seemed to cover a lot of artists I like - Broadcast was a big one. Someone mentioned Amanda Petrusich above. Her piece on Iron & Wine for Pitchfork earlier this year really impressed me.

So many more! Joan Morgan! Raquel Cepeda! Vanessa Grigoriadis! Lola Ogunnaike! Kate Silver! Nikki Darling! Margaret Wappler! Taiia Smart Young!

Ah, Jason, you can't get 'em all. But I'm glad you didn't miss Carla DeSantis!

Thanks for the mention. But lists of women--for any purpose-- are almost enough to make me want to have a sex change. Too bad I like blood even less.

Great list. I've worked with several of these folks (Evie, Jaan, amongst others) and have nothing but good things to say. But notable omissions (in my book): Amanda Petrusich (NYT, Paste, etc.) Jessica Suarez (Pitchfork, Voice, etc. etc.)

Seconding Michelle Mercer. Her books about music/musicians are smart & but accessible. Her work crosses over. She's published by major houses, I think, rather than the music book publishers.

My bad. Right after I finished the list, I already thought of several other great scribes that should be there too (including some named above in the comments). Please keep writing in to name other writers who deserve the props. People in this profession usually get too little credit and there's never enough kind words said about their work.

Great list. What about Michelle Mercer, who's reported for NPR and taken on some of the heaviest musicians around--Wayne Shorter and Joni Mitchell--in her books? http://www.michellemercer.com/

No mention of Jane Scott, the venerable rock writer for The Cleveland Plain Dealer? Scott started writing about pop music for the Plain Dealer in 1964, when the Beatles first toured the U.S., and she covered nearly every major act that played in the area until 2002. Granted, she's out of the game these days, but she was a trailblazer who took pop music seriously at a time when that was all but unknown, and in a piece on women writing about music, she at least deserves to have her name dropped.

dream hampton is one of my favorite writers of all time ever about anything ever. if she ghost wrote the dictionary, i'd read it from cover to cover...twice.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Gross lists 33 female music critics whose work you should be reading. (At [...]

  2. [...] Further Exploration: 33 Women Music Critics You Need to Read – I’m taking [...]

  3. [...] a more thorough job, and includes many of the books on my own list (and one I hated). Their list of 33 female music critics you need to read is also pretty [...]