‘One Story’ Names the Top 10 Short Stories of All Time

As a fitting finale to National Short Story Month, we asked the talented crew over at One Story to name their ten favorite epigrammatic tales. Tanya Rey, the managing editor, explained via e-mail that their choices are in no particular order, so anti-Salingerists are advised to not get all huffy just because JD leads the list. Tanya writes, “Certain authors (e.g., Cheever, Moore, Johnson, Barthleme) were nominated more than once, for different stories, so we tried to choose the most ‘classic’ of those stories. This was not exactly a scientific or objective process.” However, we stand behind the choices because they’re some of our favorites as well. What do you think, dear readers?

“For Esmé – with Love and Squalor” by JD Salinger

“For Esmé – with Love and Squalor” was originally published in 1950 in the New Yorker to great acclaim; it was later included in the collection Nine Stories. In “For Esmé…”, an American soldier is looking back on his encounter with a clever 13-year-old singer named Esmé who entreats him to write about something vile. (Lemony Snicket fans might remember Count Olaf’s fashion conscious, diabolical girlfriend, Esmé Squalor.)

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] Angel later this week as part of our all new digital compilation, Behaving Badly. In the meantime, check out the list and tell us what you think. Filed under: On Stage j = jQuery.noConflict(); var addedComment [...]

[...] week, the good people over at Flavorwire asked us to come up with what we considered to be the top ten stories of all time. This, as you [...]

[...] was a neat dodge of Flavorwire‘s request for them to list what they thought were the 10 best short stories ever. Zzzzzzzzzz. [...]

[...] to supply our brains with narrative.  NPR’s got a nice spot here, and the fine folks at Flavorpill even talked One Story into coming up with this list of the best short stories.  Short stories aren’t factually extinct, either.  They survive [...]

[...] Story has a list of the Top 10 Short Stories of all time. The New Yorker is ummmm pretty well represented here. I came up with about 30 that are [...]

[...] If you want to read a top 10 list of the best short stories ever written, click here. [...]

Which only serves to show you how disagreeing about literature can be as disagreeable as discussing politics. The New Yorker has published some of the best fiction of the century, but it can also be pretentious. Can we please get off the Gabriel Garcia Marquez track when it comes to fiction from Latin America. Another New Yorker fiction writer, Lyll Becerra de Jenkins, wrote a short story called "Tyranny," that later evolved into an award winning book, THE HONORABLE PRISON. Hellooooo, there are more writers than just Marques and Diaz from south of the border.....And speaking of New Yorker venerables, what about Ann Beattie's stories, which were a staple of the magazine for years?

and yes ZZ Packer and Marquez are on the list but their writing fits into what white people like mostly. You all did get it right with Carver and Johnson, just put us folks of color in there too because we exist tooooooooooooooooooooo.

God this is what i hate about One Story the most, it's so white bread it's crazy, how can this really be the so called top 10 short stories of all time, such hogwash, no Black writers, women, Hispanic or Asian writers, or where are the dead Russians. No Tolstoy, Capote, or Baldwin or Richard Wright.This list is way too American and straight white male. How can you not have Sonny's Blues on your list. Stop being so goddamn white bread in the fiction you chose and start to explore the rest of the world. I know it's hard for the white people at One Story and in general to think about this but there are other groups of people in this world too. Start acting like it One Story

Even leaving aside "Brownies" on a top-ten list of anything, no Trevor or Munro makes the whole thing pretty laughable

Hello, I like viewing your website. It really helped me!

In my 70s, now I still remember a short story from 1960, that to my mind has never been surpassed: The Ledge byLawrence Sargent Hall

I suppose, this is more - the best modern short stories of all time. If it were truly the best, then the classics would be on there. However, we all know the classics, who they are, what their names are - its nice to be refreshed with something my 80 year old English teacher didn't make us read.

Are you kidding me! Greatest short stories of ALL TIME? I guess this site was put together by some high school kids who haven't gotten around to reading "that old boring stuff" written before they were born. You know, stuff from Hemingway, Chekhov, Hawthorne, Bradbury, Edgar Allen Poe.

Can we please review the spelling of O. Henry? It--the O--is an initial, not a preposition... Also, THANK YOU to Mike Ehling...will everyone please read ANY other short story by Shirley Jackson so we can all stop talking about her overrated canonical one? Shirley Jackson might not be so underrated if this particular short story weren't so preposterously overrated. That's all. I only read the comments, not the list, btw...

"The Red Laugh" by Leonid Andreyev. Simply the greatest story about war ever written.

Wow, look at all these great short stories, listed beyond the top 10 - thanks to One Story for kicking off the excitement. My own two cents: Sonny's Blues, James Baldwin (others mentioned this, too). The short story is clearly alive and well!

No O'Henry or Shaw?? Of all time indeed!

Faulkner "Barn Burning." Borges--need Borges. Marquez' "The Handsomest Drowned Man in the Sea." Kafka "the Hunger Artist." I.B. Singer "Gimpel the Fool."

Henry Miller, Gogol, for sure. But reading the post and the comments, I wonder: "if Lima Barreto and Machado de Assis had written their short stories in English..." It was a pity they hadn't tried to send some stories to New Yorker. Maybe it was because the magazine didn't exist by then.

Anti-genre bias thick as a brick. Ever heard of Harlan Ellison? Ray Bradbury?

Also missing from the list is John Cheever's "The Swimmer" and James Thurber's "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty". The list is too New Yorker-centric and the fine folks at One Story (in my opinion) need to have a broader exposure.

There's a reason Kipling was the best-selling author in English for many years. Look at The Gardener or A Sahib's War or Proofs of Holy Writ or The Manner of Men or …

I really think that "The Yellow Wallpaper" by Charlotte Perkins Gilman should be included on this list! Written in 1892, I consider this story to be a contemporary of O'Connor's zero to mental meltdown in 10 pages style.

"To Room 19" by Doris Lessing. Still haunts me no matter how many times I reread it.

Okay, I'm baffled. None of these stories sound very funny to me.

When I saw the list, I wondered if my favorite, 'A Good Man Is Hard To Find' would be on it. It was. I'll have to look at the rest. This is such a subjective thing. It's like ranking your favorite movie, etc. It's really a matter of taste.

"The Familiar" by China Mieville. Superb prose from a modern master.

Puh-leeze! What a joke. The author needs to read a bit more widely, beyond 20th century American literature. Chauvinism, narcissicism and exceptionalism aren't cute, contrary to the zeitgeist. No Chekhov, no Borges, no Maupassant, no Kafka, no Murakami, etc.? Seriously? If the author sincerely thinks these are the 10 best short stories, we should all hope this person stays very far away from a classroom full of impressionable students. Very far.

I'd like to suggest Roberto Bolano's "Anne Moore's Life" and David Foster Wallace's "Good Old Neon." And judging from the list, people didn't start writing short stories until the early 20th century or so, but if we're allowed to like nineteenth century stuff, I'd like to put up Tolstoy's "The Death of Ivan Illych."

This list is absurdly biased toward writers from the United States. It's clearly written by an American MFA grad who hasn't ready widely outside recent America MFiction. I'm guessing the author realized how myopic the list is, then threw in Joyce and Marquez to try to mix it up a little. I hope HuffPo's non-American audience doesn't read this and assume that we're all so self-centered!

Like a lot of other commenters, I'd complain that the list is just way to contemporary in its choices. A few I'd definitely want to include: My number one? Definitely Henry James's THE BEAST IN THE JUNGLE, but it's possibly only a "short story" by Jamesian standards and a novella by everyone else's. Shirley Jackson? My own choice here would be AFTERNOON IN LINEN, which I love dearly. THE LOTTERY has its shock value, but once you know the twist I'm not so sure it's all that great on a re-read. Of course Joyce's THE DEAD has to be included. For Hawthorne, I'm inclined to go top-of-my-head with RAPPACCINI'S DAUGHTER, but I really need to give Hawthorne a re-read one of these days. I notice there's been no reference to sci-fi (or maybe I just missed it). Include here Octavia Butler's BLOODCHILD. For a "disjointed" monologue narration, include Charlotte Perkins Gilman's THE YELLOW WALLPAPER. My own personal love is Antonia White's THE EXILE (an hilarious case of pre-Vatican II "survivor humor"); but White, best known for her first novel FROST IN MAY, isn't that well known compared to Gilman and probably wouldn't be considered "canonical," though she has a strong following among Virago-ites. Washington Irving's RIP VAN WINKLE is almost a compulsory include. And something by Maupassant has to be included. Given my own limited knowledge of him, I'll go with his own choice of BOULE DE SUIF. Mark Twain? THE WAR PRAYER. As a tenth, I'd like to include Melville's BARTLEBY, THE SCRIVENER, but this one is almost certainly a novella. Alternatively, I'm going to go quirky and include Elizabeth Gaskell's THE GREY WOMAN, which may not be that well known but is an interesting case of transgenderism by a mid-Victorian writer who was generally considered more "respectable" than her friend Charlotte Brontë. Mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa! With the exception of Maupassant, I've gone totally English language. It's still a way better list, though, than the overly contemporary choices originally offered.

The Lottery by Shirley Jackson

I would like blogs and magazines to stop doing "top 10" lists of anything. Ultimately, those that don't make the list are much more siginificant than those that do.

Amy Bloom? Only one story not originally written in English? No Chekhov, no Welty, no Maupassant, no Henry James, no I.B. Singer, no Alistair MacLeod (so sadly underrated), no Wharton? no Lawrence? no Gogol? no Babel? no Pushkin? Seriously?

Everyone sleeps on William Trevor.

I can't believe it took until comment #34 for someone to mention Welty.

Katherine Anne Porter? Eudora Welty? Updike? Roth? Elizabeth Spencer? Thomas Mann? Tolstoy? Chekhov? Cheever? Jackson? No, I can't go on. It would take too long. Shocking to think of what is left out.

No Ambrose Bierce? No Katherine Anne Porter? "Two Gallants" has my vote along with "The Dead" & "Eveline" (and "Clay"!).

I think some of the best short stories are the ones that are really short. Not Lydia Davis short -- although some of those would surely apply -- but the ones that manage to wrestle a big story into a few pages, that deliver a very swift left hook to the reader and make the very idea of a novel seem overblown and dull. John Cheever's "The Swimmer" is an example. It has the scope of a life in about ten pages. A true work of inspiration. Another that comes to mind is Vladimir Nabokov's supremely sad and strange "Signs and Symbols," also very short. Tolstoy's "After the Ball" is another. The short story is an excruciatingly hard form to master. I think sometimes the people who do it well are born with the gift. Whenever magazines announce another "Short Story Contest," I always want to say "Why stop there? Hold a symphony contest while you're at it. Or a mathematical theorem contest."

I can only echo the "commentators" above who wrote about how totally ahistorical this list is... A reflection of the dismal state of the arts in the USA when the "judges" havent read, or couldnt properly judge anything written before 1950--- When I was coming up, no list would have omitted the O'Henry story about the crossed gifts (pardon the senior moment). Oh well, plus ca change plus ca reste le meme!!

You forgot "Beyond Lies the Wub" by Phillip K Dick. Actually, you forgot any science fiction. *sigh*

When I saw "White Angel" it just put a huge smile on my face. I don't believe in ranking systems for awesome literature, but I don't think "Brownies" is in the same league as "The A&P" or "The Five Forty Eight". Then again, this isn't my list and I love One Story. Overall, thanks. If only because this list got my Flannery Oconnor anthology off the shelf.

My gawd, all great stuff but where's "Angel Levine" by Bernard Malamud and "Perfect" by Mark Helprin? Ten stories, it's just too restrictive.

Tell Me a Riddle, Tillie Olsen Also, this list could use a little genre-diversity, with one of the great SciFi or mystery stories included.

Speaking of Bierce, Kurt Vonnegut called "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" the best piece of American literature. I'm not sure it's the best but it should be one of them. I do like how a list like this so infuriates readers that we get together and give each other more things to read.

That Evening Sun, by Faulkner

"A&P" by John Updike and "The Death of Jack Hamilton" by Stephen King.

How amazing, that all but one of the "greatest short stories ever written" was written in the columnist's lifetime. Those of us with some sense of history have already offered corrections. I would add Ambrose Bierce's "Chickamauga," possibly the best war story ever written.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] week, the good people over at Flavorwire asked us to come up with what we considered to be the top ten stories of all time. This, as you [...]

  2. [...] to supply our brains with narrative.  NPR’s got a nice spot here, and the fine folks at Flavorpill even talked One Story into coming up with this list of the best short stories.  Short stories aren’t factually extinct, either.  They survive [...]

  3. [...] Story has a list of the Top 10 Short Stories of all time. The New Yorker is ummmm pretty well represented here. I came up with about 30 that are [...]

  4. [...] If you want to read a top 10 list of the best short stories ever written, click here. [...]

  5. [...] Angel later this week as part of our all new digital compilation, Behaving Badly. In the meantime, check out the list and tell us what you think. Filed under: On Stage j = jQuery.noConflict(); var addedComment [...]

  6. [...] was a neat dodge of Flavorwire‘s request for them to list what they thought were the 10 best short stories ever. Zzzzzzzzzz. [...]