10 Notorious Literary Spats

Patrick Kingsley recently wrote in The Guardian about “poisonous literary feuds” and the peacemakers who could broker a truce. We ran a post on the subject last year, but thought we would do an international list of troublemakers this time around. We’d also like to honor the man who racked up the most hours feuding with his literary colleagues: Norman Mailer. Writers today generally aren’t as venomous toward each other (although maybe Colson Whitehead would disagree after his salivary encounter with Richard Ford). We have to agree with Mailer’s proclamation on The Dick Cavett Show: “I’m going to be the champ until one of you knocks me off.”

Colson Whitehead vs. Richard Ford

In 2002, Whitehead gave us a hilarious and scathing review of A Multitude of Sins in The New York Times. He writes, “The characters’ sense of befuddlement comes to infect, but never to enlighten, the reader.” He later notes, “At the top of the story, the protagonist offers an Awkward Pang of Simmering Dissatisfaction, which sounds suspiciously like the A.P.S.D. offered by the character in the previous story.” For this, Richard Ford spit on him at a Poets & Writers party. Afterward, Whitehead said, “This wasn’t the first time some old coot had drooled on me, and it probably won’t be the last. But I would like to warn the many other people who panned the book that they might want to get a rain poncho, in case of inclement Ford.”

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] like it?  Are they allowed to voice their opinion?  The answer is YES!  Authors have always trashed each other and very publicly for centuries.   Charles Dickens was accused of “writing to be [...]

[...] For the original report go to http://flavorwire.com/183467/10-notorious-literary-spats/4 [...]

[...] musings: Norman Mailer proving to the world what a total asshole he [...]

[...] you? Just after squashing a 15-year feud with Paul Theroux, the writer who’s also made an enemy of Derek Walcott has picked a fight with half the world’s population: women. The Guardian reports that, in an [...]

Whitehead's review of Ford's stories was brilliant and completely on target.

Just ran across this: never read of the Ford vs. Whitehead incident. A feud with words is one thing, having someone spit on you is another. Whitehead is either more gracious than I, or more sanguine. I would've punched Ford so hard his dentures would landed in the next city. And if he doesn't have dentures, he'd need them after I finished. Worst thing that ever came of a negative book review in my case was being disinvited from contributing (a profile piece) after I was asked to contribute. No big deal, since I'd already gotten the paycheck for a reprint of the article). In any case, I hope someone sets Ford straight: writing Pulitzer winning novels doesn't give anyone license to be a dick.

This is a very small point, but the past tense of the verb "to spit" is "spat." Richard Ford spits today. Richard Ford spat yesterday. Richard Ford has spat out a lot of crap in addition to some great books.

and not a very smart asshole, at that. But if you read Cavett's transcipt of the whole affair, you'll understand what happened a lot better than just what the excerpt here gives you. Link: http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/11/14/in-this-corner-norman-mailer/

There's gotta be other literary feuds. What about some poets???

Since I wrote the book on feuds, I know that you can't forget the classics bouts, like Hemingway and Max Eastman, fighting over a desk at Scribners: http://www.planetpeschel.com/index?/site/comments/hemingway_vs_eastman_1937/

And there would also be Julian Barnes versus Martin Amis. A friendship gone very badly. The Information was a lovely vicious work.

That finger bowls line easily ranks up there in one of the worst and most embarrassing comebacks ever.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] you? Just after squashing a 15-year feud with Paul Theroux, the writer who’s also made an enemy of Derek Walcott has picked a fight with half the world’s population: women. The Guardian reports that, in an [...]

  2. [...] musings: Norman Mailer proving to the world what a total asshole he [...]

  3. [...] like it?  Are they allowed to voice their opinion?  The answer is YES!  Authors have always trashed each other and very publicly for centuries.   Charles Dickens was accused of “writing to be [...]

  4. [...] 拉什迪的全面,全血,答复可以在这里阅读。 无论是谁,你同意,它总是高兴地看到两位作家争论的实质问题,而不是一些神经质的争吵,我们在过去已经处理。 [...]

  5. [...] not least because I am a chicken. Who wants to get spat on (Colson Whitehead by Richard Ford  http://www.flavorwire.com/183467/10-notorious-literary-spats ) or punched in the snout (a certain nameless Oz poet by a certain other nameless Oz [...]