10 Musicians and the Cities They Embody

The best music is universal — it transcends location and context, and manages to speak straight to your heart, no matter where you’re from. But that doesn’t mean that it can’t have a sense of place — and indeed, we got to thinking recently about how some of our favorite artists over the years have been inextricably linked with the cities where they’re based, either through their lyrical depictions of their environment or just because they’re the first artist to spring to mind when you think of the city in question. So here’s a list of ten musicians who we think embody the cities they live (or lived) in. If you can think of any more, feel free to add them in the comments.

London: Suede

To people (i.e. Americans) who know this band as “The London Suede” anyway, this might seem like cheating, but the name aside, few bands have captured the experience of England’s capital as perfectly as Suede did. A friend once told us that “you don’t really get Suede until you’ve lived in London” — and sure enough, after a couple of years of grafting it out in basement flats, living on Tesco toast and Tetley’s tea, copping cheap E’s, and doing our best to live out the Wildean cliché of being in the gutter and looking at the stars, Suede’s tales of council estates and desperate hedonism did indeed make perfect, perfect sense.

Key lyric: “With all the love and poison of London…”

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Big misfire on S.F. 2nd the Dead/Sly nomination. Spot on. I'd add a third -- Dead Kennedys to mirror the rabble rousing (what's left of it) contingent. We could use more of that spirit round here these days...

Atlanta = Outkast. End of story.

Bakersfield, CA = Korn. Now the list is complete. I'm kidding! I'd like to add Too $hort for Oakland, Luther Campbell/2 Live Crew for Miami, and N.W.A (plus all their spinoff solo careers) for Los Angeles- as someone earlier mentioned. What about San Diego?

@Frances: Argh - that is indeed a typo, and a somewhat unfortunate one given the context. Thanks for pointing it out - I've fixed it now.

This isn't a criticism, just what I think is a typo. In the Muddy Water section you say, "The Great Migration bought about two million African Americans out of the south, and roughly 600,000 of them went to Chicago. They brought with them the sound of the Delta Blues, and as a result, Chicago became the great outpost of the blues north of the Mason-Dixon line." Did you mean brought when you say bought in the first sentence?

Me And Bobby McGee was written by Kris Kristofferson...

london...suede interesting but what about the libertines, sex pistols, the clash

@Oi! - I often ask myself the same question...

Why, why, why do I scroll through the comments sections! I'm outa here.

Lyrics from the Belleville Three: "We don't really need a crowd to have a party, just a funky beat and you to get it started" Big Fun, Inner City

I'm sorry to add to the chorus of criticisms here, but Jacques Brel couldn't really represent Paris since he's from Belgium. He sang both in french and dutch and I could list you songs he wrote about Brussels, Belgium, Liège, Brugge and Gent but not a single one about Paris.

@whitemarks - oh, not to worry, I'm used to it. The joys of the internet and anonymous commenting, I'm afraid. But yeah, that was the idea, musicians who embody popular conceptions of these cities, whether or not those conceptions are actually based in reality. Perhaps I could have explained it a bit better, but so it goes. And thanks for being gracious, regardless :)

@Tom H - If I'd have foreseen the torrent of criticism you were about to inherit here I would have surely modulated my tongue. Clichés it is then! Now what to do about "Of Montreal"?

You guys do realize that Motown Records was in Detroit, right?

@Poorvi - and where exactly did I say that the lyrics cited were from "Le poinçonneur des Lilas"? I'm well aware that those particular lyrics are from "Rues de Mon Paris" (the clue is the fact that "Rues de Mon Paris" is, um, in the lyrics). You'll also notice that the Smiths, Janis Joplin and Muddy Waters lyrics don't correspond with the embedded song, which is really just there for your listening pleasure (and, in that particular case, because I mentioned it in the text below. Sometimes, not everything is on YouTube, sadly. I don't mind people having a go at me for things I *have* said, but accusing me of a "clear lack of knowledge" on the basis of a mistaken assumption on your part is a bit much.

Red Hot Chili Peppers, Doors, Los Lobos, N.W.A. - L.A., it's just that big

Grateful Dead, Sly and the Family Stone, far better embody the cliche that is SF.

Being a Serge fan, I know this song. I actually listened to it 3 times wondering why I hadn't heard these lyrics before? Oh yes, it's because they don't exist! The lyrics you've listed are for the song 'Rues de mon Paris' (a duo sung with Dalida) not 'Le poinçonneur des Lilas'. I don't think one should be entitled to do a list like this when they make a mistake like that. There's a clear lack of knowledge here.

Leonard Cohen — Montreal.

Sorry, but, one of these things is not like the other. Insert shoe-horn. Atlanta, sure... Since you're offering up a token hip hop nod, ummm Ludacri-- really? Not so sure about that one, kiddies. You mention Outkast as if they weren't signed well before Ludacris, like say 7-8 years prior. They were a clear catalyst and oodles more marked in putting Atlanta and Southern hip hop on the map.

@whitemarks - at the risk of feeding the trolls, the fact that these musicians are identified with city-based clichés was the whole point of the feature in the first place...

Joplin rose to fame in Austin a died Los Angeles. SF was a blip on the map. Speaking of Austin, where is it on this list. And where is Stevie Ray Vaughn? Beach Boys and the south bay?

I forgive editors for their top 10 lists and I forgive music journalists for the literary bias they bring by the armload to the musical arts. But even with a hat full of forgiveness I can't be other than quaintly embarrassed by the lack of understanding and the knee-jerk pandering to bygone-era cliches that form the ill-fitting foundation of this list.

Wayne Cochran for Miami.

bone thugs n harmony for cleveland

It seems a bit obvious, but what about Nirvana and Seattle?

Salem, for Detroit. You're welcome.

the Weakerthans, Winnipeg or for the US - the Strokes, NYC.

the Weakerthans, Winnipeg or for the US - the Strokes, NYC

bruce spingsteen- new jersey

Fixed it is. Isaac Hayes- Memphis Archie Bell & The Drells- Houston

Elvis + Memphis ZZ Top + Houston (just because it's funny)

Bah, and I was only there a few weeks ago, too. I know it's south of the Strip, but it was an old Gunners hang-out - apparently they used to play in the venue next door, and get brutally hungover breakfasts at Canter's afterward. But thanks for being that guy, regardless (and being pleasant about it) - fixed.

Kantor's diner on Melrose? 1. It's Canter's Deli. 2. It's on Fairfax. 3. It's a good mile and a half south of the strip. Sorry to be THAT guy, but only takes a minute or two on google to tighten it up.