10 Side Projects That Are Better Than the Primary Band

Earlier this week, we had the privilege of hearing the new Atlas Sound record. Our professional opinion thus far is that the album is really good, and it got us thinking about how much more we like Bradford Cox’s solo project than his work with Deerhunter. Anyway, this in turn got us thinking about other cases where we’ve enjoyed a musician’s side project more than their “real” band. We’ve pulled together a selection of our favorites after the jump, and for these purposes, we’re calling anything formed while the musician was still in their former band a side project (so Sebadoh count, but a band like, say, New Order doesn’t). Anyway, as ever, we’d love to hear your suggestions.

Atlas Sound

Deerhunter have certainly had their moments — in particular, we were big fans of Microcastle — but listening to their extended psych jams (especially in a live setting) can be like being punched in the head repeatedly by a large man. On his own, Cox seems to embrace the subtlety that his band often lack, and the songs are the better for it.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] You know when that band’s side project is better than that band you like itself? [...]

Wolf Parade is a tricky one. Can you really call them the primary band? When you're juggling Sunset Rubdown, Frog Eyes, Wolf Parade, Atlas Strategic, and Handsome Furs, I think the only concrete argument is that Handsome Furs is the most recent of these 5 bands. Also, I would like for someone to clarify an album from this group that was a better work than "Apologies to the Queen Mary." Sunset Rubdown > Wolf Parade, MAYBE. But Handsome Furs? Come on.

i have an aversion to all things snobish.

as far as being a live band goes, atoms for peace certainly gives radiohead a run for their money. which isn't to say that the radiohead shows i've seen weren't amazing. just that the atoms for peace shows were really really really amazing...

A Perfect Circle was better than Tool...then they put out a second album that sounded JUST LIKE TOOL. Ugh.

This list should've been titled Just as Good Side Projects because the majority, in my opinion, weren't better than their primaries.

I disagree about Deerhunter. While it might be true for other albums, their most recent effort (2010's Halcyon Digest) is by far much more impressive than Cox's Atlas Sound recordings.

Damn man, judging by the coimment there must be some seriously amazing and well imformed music journalists out there... or not.. It would appear from the venom here that this writer is commting the equivilant of infant genocide when they offer up opinions like ten side projects they enjoy on this or any other site. Oh dear, oh dear. I'll just offer that I enjoyed the list.

Actually cuz, This Great Heights was written by Gibbard, Sam Beam later covered it.

This list sucks ass except Fever Ray comparison.

Jack White: Raconteurs, Dead Weather > White Stripes Dave Grohl: Them Crooked Vultures > Nirvana, Foo Fighters Julian Casablancas: solo > The Strokes Damon Albarn: Gorillaz > BLur, The Good, Bad, Queen

such great heights was written by sam beam, a.k.a. iron & wine.

Yes to Atlas Sound, This Mortal Coil and Tom Tom Club. Agree with the suggestion for Electronic, as well. I'd also throw the name Twilight Circus Dub Sound System in as the amazing side project of Ryan Moore from Legendary Pink Dots...

I prefer Jamie xx solo stuff to the xx

I would say Electronic, Bernard Sumner's side project with Johnny Marr except they sound almost exactly like New Order anyway.

I must add this preamble to my comment because I have been a serious fan of Nick Cave's work since his early days with the Boys Next Door in the 70's. Birthday Party blew my mind (one of my absolute favorite shows in 1981 (or '82?) was when he played Chicago at my fave punk club)and, for me, his work with the Bad Seeds was out-of-this-world...until the last several albums (with the stellar exception of "Dig, Lazarus, Dig"). The last albums that I truly loved listening to start-to-finish and on repeat were "Let Love In", "No More Shall We Part", and "Dig, Lazarus, Dig." There were some songs on the Murder Ballads that I liked, but I wasn't a rabid fan of it. Something was lost for me -- maybe too many love songs and back up choirs. But, holy CRAP...when he formed Grinderman? It was like he stepped out of a haze and rediscovered himself. Really does make me think of a true blend of old Birthday Party's sonic garage elements with earlier Bad Seeds' dark, post-punk. They only have 2 albums out so far, but I honestly can't wait to see where he takes this project. AND his soundtrack work with Warren Ellis has been fucking incredible, not to mention the early stuff he did with Die Haut and so much else.

Kevin (above) got it right. This post is more 10 side-projects you could think of rather than 10 that are better than the primary band. I happen to prefer Deerhunter to Atlas Sound. The Breeders over the Pixies. Come on! The only thing missing from this list is The Glove over The Cure.

Interesting piece. But have you actually heard "Trompe Le Monde"? It would never occur to me that anybody could think of the Pixies final album as "lackluster". Re: "Planet of Sound", "U-Mass", "The Sad Punk", "Subbacultcha", "Lovely Day", "Alec Eiffel". All blistering. "Bossanova" and "Trompe Le Monde" rarely get enough credit.

Man I also find Death Cab to be a harsh toke.

Atlas Sound maybe.. but Idk about Panda Bro. He has one superb album (Person Pitch) while AnCo has 4 at least.

Not technically a side project, but what about Wings (the band the Beatles could have been)?

Article title should be "10 Side Projects We Could Think Of". Tom Tom Club? Really?

A Perfect Circ... SHIT... you gotta be kiddin me

My vote would go to Menomena, side project of Lackthereof.

Yeah, srry, Panda Bro is pretty great but he's not better than AnCo. Also agree w/ Russ. However, Sunset Rubdown would have been appropriate for this list.

Handsome Furs > Wolf Parade, also

How about Sunset Rubdown over Wolf Parade?

This Mortal Coil was awesome, but they were in no way better than the Cocteau Twins.

Fever Ray > The Knife? INCORRECT. Oh, Tom Hawking, we meet again.