10 of Rock ‘n’ Roll’s Most Underrated Lyricists

When the discussion of the finest lyricists in rock ‘n’ roll comes up, you tend to hear the same names mentioned again and again. Bob Dylan. Leonard Cohen. Tom Waits. Morrissey. Nick Cave. Warren Zevon. They’re all worthy choices, for sure, but we find it a bit sad that there are plenty of other fantastic lyricists who never seem to make their way into such conversations. After the jump, we’ve put together a collection of lyricists who we reckon don’t get the credit they deserve, either because their music is generally undervalued or because their skills in other areas tend to overshadow their linguistic talents. Let us know in the comments who else you reckon doesn’t get the lyrical love they should do.

James Mercer

The world at large still knows The Shins as that band Natalie Portman’s character in Garden State kept raving about, and even casual fans may find themselves humming along with the band’s infectious melodies without ever really stopping to think what the lyrics are all about. If you take the time to listen, though, you’ll find that Mercer really does have a way with both words and startling imagery — we’re particularly fond of “Pink Bullets” on Chutes Too Narrow, with its descriptions of a broken love affair as like “a book you read in reverse/ So you understand less as the pages turn/ Or a movie so crass and awkwardly cast/ That even I could be the star.”

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] Zappa Beth Gibbons Dee Dee Ramone Iggy Pop Harriet Wheeler Andy Falkous Owen Ashworth Brian Eno Flavorwire Overrated Lou Reed Paul Banks Serj Tankian Bernard Sumner Matt Bellamy Conor Oberst Jim Morrison [...]

[...] week we ran a post on the people who we thought were rock ‘n’ roll’s most underrated lyricists — artists who don’t get the credit they deserve for their writing, either because [...]

Curtis (Meat Puppets) Kirkwood routinely did what Eno claims to have done, only better. Most of the Meat Puppets songs were completely worked out musically first, then lyrics were added with a priority on sound and phonetics before lyrical message.

Mr Townes van zandt... God bless the mans soul!

Bill Mallonee of Vigilantes of Love

Jason Lytle of Grandaddy Jeff Mangum of Neutral Milk Hotel. Everyone raves about Aeroplane Over the Sea but On Avery Island is chock full of great lyrics

Bradley Nowell - Sublime ....if I had a shotgun, you know just what I'd do, I'd point that shit straight at the sky, and shoot heaven on down for you....

I was really hoping that Andy Partridge of XTC was finally going to get some much deserved love here, but no, once again, the most under-rated lyricist in the world goes under-rated again. But points for including Zappa.

i've always thought andrew bird is underrated as a lyricist. his wordplay, while maybe not 'deep', is always very clever.

None better than Ian Anderson of Jethro Tull. Best unnoticed: "Baker Street Muse" from the "Minstrel in the Gallery" album. "Pig Me and the Whore" section is a classic.

Tom MARSHALL Swinging on the lifeline Fraying bits of twine Entangled in the remnants of the Knot I left behind And asking you to help me make it Finally unwind ...And when the line is breaking And when I'm near the end When all the time spent leading I've been following instead When all my thoughts and memories are Left hanging by a thread

Tom Marshall - Swinging on the lifeline Fraying bits of twine Entangled in the remnants of the Knot I left behind And asking you to help me make it Finally unwind And when the line is breaking And when I'm near the end When all the time spent leading I've been following instead When all my thoughts and memories are Left hanging by a thread

Dave Bielanko. Marah "My heart is the schoolyard so empty Vacant of smiles and void of all joy My heart is the ghetto at midnight Teeming with beats that reverberate fear My heart is the newspaper blowin’ Down the street when it’s snowin’ and no one's around My heart is a saxophone solo from a third story window Just before dawn"

Yay george! I will second the Rhett Miller nod, and also Will Sheff as mentioned by Matt B.

jason molina (songs: ohia, magnolia electric co.) kevin barnes (of montreal) - has the distinction of writing songs using simple language and relateable imagery (e.g. tim, i wish you were born a girl) and also songs using complex language and allusions (e.g. the past is a grotesque animal), both to stunning effect.

Layne Staley from Alice in Chains. RIP.

damien jurado chad vangaalen j. mascis phil elvrum (the microphones and mount eerie)

Ben Folds Jeff Tweedy Jason Falkner

Black Francis and Kristin Hersh come to mind for me (as additions). I saw someone mention John Darnielle, too, and I fully concur, as I do with the rest of the list. Glad to see Owen Ashworth get some love, as well. Why people feel the need to turn a top 10 list of underrated lyricists into a dick-measuring contest is beyond me. We all have dicks, people, and they are all wonderful. Figuratively speaking.

Dar Williams. You will not find a presently producing artist more brilliantly talented at composition/lyrics than she. I guarantee it.

dear MICHAEL: do you know what the word "underrated" means? and you are so very wrong about leonard cohen, my friend. "hundreds" better than him? that's laughable, as no doubt the names on that list would be.

*clears throat* Willy Vlautin, Mark Kozelek, John Grant, Jeff Tweedy, Will Oldham, Brian Fallon, Brendan Benson, Courtney Taylor-Taylor, Josh T Pearson, Tunde Adebimpe. And that's just off the top of my head.

How can you leave out Will Sheff from Okkervil River? He's probably the best lyricist working today! "Marie's passed out in a chair/and her once fussed-over hair's/all mussed into an I've just been fucked shape" - from "You Can't Hold the Hand of a Rock and Roll Man" "So some line someone told/says even light can get old/oh, slobbering lovers, drink clinking brothers/they don't have to tell us, because we know" - from "Lay of the Last Survivor" The guy has been nominated for only one Grammy, and it was for liner notes he wrote for someone else's album.

for starters, i LOVE JA's veraline suggestion. spot on 'cuz tv was a symbolist's dream. and i totally agree w/ flavorpill's inclusion of brian eno here....inscrutably delicious. i can't tell you how many times i've waded thru 'mother whale eyeless' and have either died laffing or just stared out the window in amazement. i think jeff mangum of neutral milk hotel should get a nod here....if only by virtue of his appearance at last week's wall street demonstrations, this guy is a keeper. great topic, flavorpill....well-covered by editors & readers alike. cheers!

I second JillHives's nomination of John K. Sampson of The Weakerthans. He is not just a great lyricist but a tremendous story teller. His songs read like some of the best short fiction out there.

No James Murphy? Shame on you, Flavorwire. How can you beat a line like "Drunk girls know that love is an astronaut; it comes back, but it's never the same" or "I heard that everybody that you know is more relevant than everybody that I know."? I put him up there with Cave and Waits and Cohen.

No robert pollard?! What the fuck?

The sadness and longing of Iggy Pop's "I Wanna Be Your Dog" definitely earns him a place here. I'd add ex-Velvet Undergrounder John Cale, not least for "Dying On The Vine"- "I've been chasing ghosts and I don't like it/I wish someone would show me where to draw the line/I'd lay down my sword if you would take it/And tell everyone back home I'm doing fine." And the Magnitic Fields' Stephin Merritt for the amazing lyrics, "on the ferris wheel/looking out on coney island/under more stars than/there are prostitutes in thailand." And most underrated would have to be the late, great leader of The Cramps, the one and only Lux Interior!

Especially if one of that hundred is NEIL SEDAKA. Ye gods.

Oh, for goodness' sake. A lot of the people you cite are excellent and justly successful pop songwriters, but that doesn't make them excellent lyricists (or, in the case of Elton John, lyricists at all). Case in point: Paul "Fixing a Hole" McCartney? Really? Really? If you think there are "a hundred rock writers far better and more culturally significant" than Leonard Cohen, I suggest you have a very different definition of what makes a good song lyric to me.

Rock's finest lyricists are "Bob Dylan, Leonard Cohen, Tom Waits, Morrissey, Nick Cave and Warren Zevon"? Are you JOKING? Dylan qualifies, but the others are basically cult favorites. The writers of rock lyrics which have most connected with people are folks like John Lennon and Paul McCartney, Barry Mann & Cynthia Weil, Jerry Leiber & Mike Stoller, Kal Mann & Dave Appel, Holland-Dozier-Holland, Smokey Robinson, Mick Jagger and Keith Richard, Neil Sedaka and Howard Greenfield, Elton John and Bernie Taupin, Carole King and Jerry Goffin, Doc Pomus and Mort Shuman and on and on and on and on. I could list a hundred rock writers far better and more culturally significant than Cohen, Waits, Morrissey, Cave and Zevon. Rock 'n' roll has been around for more than SIXTY years -- and before one starts assigning titles like "rock's finest lyricists," I would suggest they actually study the depth, breadth and full content of rock 'n' roll through the years.

"There are nights when I think Sal Paradise was right. Boys and Girls in America have such a sad time together. Sucking off each other at the demonstrations Making sure their makeup’s straight Crushing one another with colossal expectations. Dependent, undisciplined, and sleeping late." courtesy of craig finn of the hold steady, no list of rock lyricists (especially not one of underrated ones) is complete without him...

I wouldn't say Darnielle was under-rated, though...

John Darnielle of the Mountain Goats, geez.

"I couldn't help but thinking about their pussies" More gold from Iggy later.

Glenn Richards - Augie March. Man is a genius!

@H - ah, yes, excellent call on Honus Honus...

Beck! Honus Honus from Man Man!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] week we ran a post on the people who we thought were rock ‘n’ roll’s most underrated lyricists — artists who don’t get the credit they deserve for their writing, either because [...]

  2. [...] Zappa Beth Gibbons Dee Dee Ramone Iggy Pop Harriet Wheeler Andy Falkous Owen Ashworth Brian Eno Flavorwire Overrated Lou Reed Paul Banks Serj Tankian Bernard Sumner Matt Bellamy Conor Oberst Jim Morrison [...]