Critically Acclaimed Authors Who Never Win Prizes

This week marks the release of Anita Desai’s newest book, The Artist of Disappearance, a set of three beautiful novellas revolving around the shifting tides of Indian culture in past and present. We love Desai’s work, and we know critics love her too — but we noticed that, somehow, she is continually overlooked when it comes to major prizes. Always the bridesmaid and never the bride, as it were, she has been shortlisted three times for the Booker Prize without yet snapping up a win. Perplexed, we decided to take a look at other authors who have been robbed of prizes that we (and often, hordes of fans) think should be rightfully theirs. Click through to read our list of critically acclaimed authors who never win prizes — or never win that one particular prize — and let us know who else you think has been totally shafted in the comments.

Anita Desai

The wonderful Anita Desai is one of the few writers to have been shortlisted for the Booker Prize three times without ever actually winning it. From what we can see, frequent shortlisters usually end up with the prize at some point, but in our opinion, Desai has been robbed up until this point, and we’re anxiously for her much-deserved Booker waiting. Here’s hoping that The Artist Of Disappearance is our winner!

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Face it, there are not enough prizes, and thankfully more than enough fine writing to go around. Why not focus on those who should not have won? The pair of Swedish nonentity/judges instead of Nabokov or Bellow is a great start.

I'm disappointed. You could have focused on some deserving writers who haven't received their due. Instead, you have a list of highly-respected luminaries, living and dead, whose lack of winning this or that prize is of little account. Prizes are largely a matter of luck, not talent.

To paraphrase Frank Zappa: A critic is someone who can't write, writing about people who can't talk, for people who don't read.

Aren't you aware that awards are nothing but popularity contests? And not the book kind of popularity either. It's all about whose publishers' arse you kiss and how many times that really matters.

No Haruki Murakami? I am not sure 1Q84 is the best of his but Wind Up Bird Chronicle is sooo good I can't figure out why he's so overlooked.