The Best Made-For-TV Movies of All Time

Folded in among today’s DVD releases, presumably overlooked amid your Twilight sequels and Harold and Kumar 3D yuletides and “Shakespeare didn’t write his plays!” screeds, is one of 2011′s best films: The Sunset Limited, written by Cormac McCarthy, directed by Tommy Lee Jones, starring Jones and Samuel L. Jackson. Wait, you might be thinking. (You might be!) What a fine pedigree! What an excellent cast! I would have gone to see that! Did it not play at my local art house or multiplex? No, hypothetical reader, it did not. It was made for HBO, and since Sunset Limited, based on McCarthy’s play, is primarily a two-handed conversation piece about race, class, mortality, and despair, it’s probably not surprising that it found a home on a pay cable network rather than at a Hollywood studio. But this is nothing new; dialogue and intellect-driven efforts like this migrated to television long ago, as studios lost interest in telling small stories.

Since they started airing in the mid-1960s, TV movies have taken risks — either on subject matter or on rising young talent. The results weren’t always commendable; there’s a reason that the phrase “made-for-TV movie” calls up images of Tori Spelling cowering on Lifetime, or broadcast networks airing simultaneous dramatizations of the lurid Amy Fisher story. But between the networks and cable, we’ve seen an assortment of genuinely beguiling television movies; we’ve gathered ten of our favorites after the jump, with plenty of room for yours in the comments. (And, just to keep it simple, we’ve steered clear of miniseries, documentaries, and films like The Believer that were intended for theatrical release but premiered on television instead).

Brian’s Song

This true story of the friendship between cancer-stricken Wake Forest University football star Brian Piccolo (James Caan) and Chicago Bears Hall of Famer Gale Sayers (Billy Dee Williams) premiered in 1971 on the ABC Movie of the Week. It won three Emmy Awards (for teleplay, supporting actor, and Best Dramatic Program) and even saw a subsequent theatrical release; director Buzz Kulik, having directed one of the best television films of the 1970s, went on to direct one of the worst, 1974′s notoriously dopey Bad Ronald. But Brian’s Song’s legacy cast a long shadow; it was remade in 2001 (with Mekhi Phifer in the Williams role), and until Field of Dreams came along, this was considered the definitive “male weepie.”

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

OK, now for the chicks' list: 'Tribes' (all time 2nd fave - Jan Michael Vincent), 'Lizzie Borden' (Elizabeth Montgomery), 'Sybil' (Sally Field), 'Maybe I'll Come Home in the Spring' (all time 2nd fave -Sally Field again), 'Go Ask Alice' (all-time fave - William Shatner and Andy Griffith are in unusual roles in this one), 'The Black Dahlia' (Lucy Arnaz), 'The Best Little Girl in the World' (Jennifer Jason Leigh), and that scary Karen Black movie everyone talks about above that I thought no one else remembered until today. Break out the Fiddle Faddle!

"My Sweet Charlie" (1970) "Tribes" (1970) "Murder by Natural Causes" (1979) "Dr. Cook's Garden" (1971) "Crowhaven Farm" (1969) "Welcome Home Johnny Bristol" (1972) Just a few efforts from the early years that still hold up well.

"The Dollmaker" with Jane Fonda. Aired in 1984 on ABC. I still remember how bleak and moving it was, especially when Fonda's character loses a daughter in a train accident. Very powerful. Fonda won an Emmy for her role. Most people won't remember it against other made for tv movies of the 80s, but if you get a chance, see it.

Duel is nothing short of a masterpiece. It may just be my favorite Spielberg film and shows the birth of a genius.

Great article, and prompted a lot of thinking from me about which TV movies were my all-time favorites. I don't really agree with a lot of the choices here -- "Gia" is just so overrated, to me (and is definitely filmed with a prurient air). I do agree with "The Day After," however. I was a little kid but I remember that Karen Black Trilogy of Terror episode with the doll and it SCARRED ME FOR LIFE, PEOPLE. Still. Can't even think about it without getting the raging heebiejeebies. Mine would have to include: "Playing for Time" (1980, Redgrave) "Somebody Has to Shoot the Picture" (really underrated, and Roy Scheider and Arliss Howard were amazing) "And the Band Played On" (incredible film; literate, suspenseful, and moving) "Great Expectations" (Gryffydd version, just gorgeously done) "Angels in America" (although isn't this officially a miniseries? Regardless, it was staggering and gorgeous.) "Anne of Green Gables" (Follows version) "Wit" (Emma Thompson) "Lonesome Dove" (I know it's a miniseries but it's so good who cares) "The Executioner's Song" (see above. TL Jones is ah-mazing) "Temple Grandin" (agree with Claire Danes's Mom {hee}, and seriously? Claire was even more amazing this year on "Homeland," just a fantastic show) "The Shadowbox" (Plummer, Woodward, et al) "Fail Safe" (the live remake with Clooney and Dreyfuss from 2000) "The Legend of Lizzie Borden" (Elizabeth Montgomery) "Sybil" -- even if the case has since been debunked, the movie was fantastic. Cheers!

COMPANIONS IN NIGHTMARE with Melvyn Douglas, Gig Young, Dana Wynter, Patrck O'Neal, Ann Baxter, William Redfield, Lou Gossett and a score by Bernard Herman--alas, unavailable on video!

My daughter,Claire Danes, won a Golden Globe and an Emmy last year for "Temple Grandin". People seemed to learn a lot about Autisim and also seemed to like it. ( HBO ).

Sorry, Brian's Song may be famous, but it's really not great. Extremely syrupy and sentimental is more like it. Gia is great only as high camp, and would not be out of place on a double bill with Mommie Dearest. I second the earlier mention of Execution of Private Slovik.

The Dark Secret of Harvest Home, a mini-series from 1978 starring Bette Davis is right up there (in my opinion) with Trilogy of Terror and Don't be Afraid of the dark - all great, creepy 70s movies.

Katherine, starring Sissy Spacek as a militant 60's revolutionary. Can be found in a cheesy collection at Costco or Walmart or one of those places. A powerful statement, very early in the game.

Enthusiastically seconded: "Special Bulletin" and "Testament," and then wasn't "Threads," essentially the British "The Day After," a BBC production? "Rona Jaffe's Mazes and Monsters" was six kinds of awesome. On a more somber note: "Something About Amelia" with teenaged Roxana Zal being molested by her father Ted Danson. It was so important that they went with a popular comedic actor, who played a good guy on his sitcom, as the father, instead of someone who was already associated with playing a creep or a heavy, like a mid-'80s equivalent of a Michael Emerson or Michael Imperioli.

Trilogy of Terror was awesome. Here's 3 other phenomenal made for TV movies from the 70's: "Rookie of the Year" - An After School Special from '73 starring Jodie Foster as the only girl on a little league baseball team. Young Jodie made a very convincing tomboy. "Like Normal People" - Shaun Cassidy plays a mentally challenged young man who falls in love with a mentally challenged young woman and they decide to get married and live independently. Talk about your must see TV. If "Simple Jack" were a real movie, it would be the perfect double bill with "Like Normal People." "Bad Ronald" - Glossed over in your "Brian's Song" review, this movie perfectly straddles the line between bizarre and terrible. It's about a misfit teen who accidentally kills a neighbor and then his mother hides him in a secret room. When the mother passes on, Ronald is still living in the house when the new family moves in. Two words: Jean Yuss.

HBO's "Grey Gardens" was amazing!

SECRET NIGHT CALLER with ROBERT REED.

"Amber Waves". Great Americana, great performances from Dennis Weaver, Kurt Russell and a very young Mare Winningham.

@mintonmedia- "Thank the lord I get to vote for those things and you don’t, Mr. Bailey." Well, I do get to vote for smuggest comment-- and I think we might have a winner!!!

Before "You Don't Know Jack", Al Pacino redemmed himself in the best HBO movie ever, "Angels in America". Jeffery Wright and Meryl Streep kick ass!!!!

Francis Ford Coppola's legendary 1972 TV movie "The People" starring Kim Darby and William Shatner. I say "legendary" because it hasn't been officially released as a DVD and only exists as a subpar, blurry VHS memory.

"Haunts of The Very Rich" "The Love War" Both starring Lloyd Bridges and both from that period in the 70's when ABC Movies of The Week were producing some really fine and nifty horror/thrillers. There's another one that I can never remember the name of with James Brolin as a man who accidentally gets locked in a department store after closing with the vicious guard dogs.

Congratulations. Except for INDICTMENT, you missed all of my favorites. To name but three: BOYCOTT (2001) Jeffrey Wright as a believably flawed, living-and-breathing MLK facing leadership for the first time in the Montgomery bus boycott, brilliantly, eclectically directed by "Homicide" alumnus Clark Johnson, with the best score EVER in a TV movie RKO 281 (1999) Leiv Schreiber as Orson Welles, John Malcovitch as co-writer Herman Mankiewicz, James Cromwell as William Randolph Hearst and Melanie Griffith in the performance of her life as Marion Davies, telling the story behind CITIZEN KANE. Nuff said? CITIZEN X (1995) The true story of the USSR's notorious serial-killer, starring Steven Rea, Max von Sydow and Donald Sutherland, this makes SILENCE OF THE LAMBS seem glib, shallow and trivial and won a Golden Globe, Emmy and Writers Guild Award. Thank the lord I get to vote for those things and you don't, Mr. Bailey. While the films you chose were all well worth seeing (and thanks for the tip on the Rossellini, the only one of the ten I haven't seen), they were hardly, as advertised, "The Best Made-For-TV Movies of All Time".

Summer of My German Soldier, seconded.

BBC's Gormenghast produced in 1999, starring the up-and-coming Jonathan Rhys Meyers. It was creepy and fantastical.

I couldn't finish The Sunset Limited. There's WAY too much nonsensical god-talk in it.

HBO's TUSKEGEE AIRMEN, with Laurence Fishburne -- a much better movie on the subject than George Lucas' far more expensive, very disappointing RED TAILS. HBO has just released a remastered blue ray version of this important story of heroism.

Haikus are easy But sometimes they don't make sense Refrigerator

A Friendship in Vienna - to be fair, I don't think I've seen it since it aired in 1988, and it may be dated now, but it made quite an impact on me as a child. With Ed Asner, Jane Alexander, a young John Cameron Mitchell, and the girl who grew up to be Rilo Kiley.

Summer of my German Soldier.

I was 10 when The Day After aired. My parents went to church to watch it, leaving me... alone! There was a lot of hype around that movie, so of course I watched it. Hadn't seen the nuke attack sequence since then. Still scares me.

You forgot the highly imitated and influential THE NIGHT STALKER produced by Dan Curtis, directed by John Moxey and starring Darren McGavin as a reporter in Las Vegas who begins to suspect a series of killings is not merely a serial killer, but a vampire. Johnny Depp is set to remake it, THE X-FILES would have never happened without it, it was the highest-rated TV movie for over 12 years and even spawned a TV movie sequel (the also impressive THE NIGHT STRANGLER) and a TV series (the immortal KOLCHAK: THE NIGHT STALKER) though your choices are pretty good. Yes, TV movies used to be interesting all the time.

The Hallmark Hall of Fame adaptation of THE BLACKWATER LIGHTSHIP features three great female lead performances and always makes me weep. And I second the love for THE GATHERING. Oh, and SPECIAL BULLETIN!

This list means nothing without Born Innocent. Broom handle.

"The Gathering" with Ed Asner and Sada Thompson is a Christmastime made for TVer that never gets too sentimental or treacly, as cancer is part of the picture, too.

Bang the Drum Slowly, starring a very young Robert DiNiro.

Mr. and Mrs. Bo Jo Jones, Desi Arnaz, Jr.

The Execution of Private Slovik, a 1974 made for TV movie starring Martin Sheen, was an amazing movie. Sheen would have won the Best Actor Emmy but he made it clear at the time that he wouldn't accept it.

WILDFLOWER with Patricia Arquette as an abused deaf chick & Reese Witherspoon http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0103266/

HBO's "And The Band Played On" is still my all-time favorite.

Trilogy of Terror still scares me. I will not watch Amelia. No, no, no. The rest sent chills down my spine for the emotional toll they took on me. Good picks indeed.

Two more that should get a mention just because the cast was amazing. "What the Deaf Man Heard" staring Matthew Modine, Claire Bloom, Judith Ivey, James Earl Jones,Jerry O'Connell, Bernadette Peters, Tom Skerritt and Jake Weber. "Sara, Plain and Tall" Glenn Close, Christopher Walken and James Rebhorn. Both were exceptionally charming.

1984, The Burning Bed with Farrah Fawcett. Really brought the issue of domestic violence to the mainstream and turned FF from a glorified beauty queen into a sort-of respected actress. 1985's Stone Pillow focused on homelessness with Lucille Ball in a rare dramatic role. Both a bit on the melodramatic side but definitely more than your typical made-for-TV fare.

Com'on! Where is "Mazes and Monsters"? This informed the US parents D&D players were all delusional homicidal satanists.

Testament. It was a PBS made for tv movie that wound up getting a theatrical release and it was amazing for its simplicity and horror and compassion.

Seconding Wit (or more precisely W;t) and throwing in a vote for HBO's (dammit!) Angels in America. Beautiful production and great acting all around (especially from Pacino!). You can't always find a theater staging the show, but you CAN always slap in the Angels in America DVD and get swept away all over again.

"Something Evil" - also directed by Steven Spielberg. Very scary movie from the '70's. Starred Sandy Dennis, Darren McGavin, Johnny Whitaker.

HBO's Wit directed by Mike Nichols with Emma Thompson and Christopher Lloyd.

That Certain Summer starring Hal Holbrook and Martin Sheen.

"And the Band Played On" and "Live from Baghdad"

Red Rock West! So good it went theatrical.