For co-star Jake M. Johnson (above right, with co-star Karan Soni), the role of Darius’ boss Jeff is a total 180 from his most familiar role. He plays one of the nicest guys on television on New Girl, and Jeff is, well, not a nice guy — at least not in the beginning. “I’m not a guy who has to be a lead in a movie,” Johnson says. “But if I’m in a movie, I want a real journey. So if I see a real arc, and I see scenes and sequences that I really wanna do, especially in a little indie where you’re not getting paid a lot of money and you’re not living comfortably, I think, ‘that actual day, that sequence, will be really fun to shoot.'” He’s not bothered by the less charming elements of Jeff’s personality. “I’ll only play a character where, deep down, I have to think I would be okay to get a drink with this person. And Jeff, when he’s being really mean, can get to be a little bit much. But if I know Jeff’s whole story, I would be okay with Jeff.”
Plaza agrees, and admits that there is certainly an April Ludgate element to her personality. “It’s definitely a part of me,” she says. “Every character that people play is a part of them, so it’s definitely in me, of course. But there’s more to me than that.” And as proof, she offers up her next big leading role, in a sex comedy currently titled The To-Do List but initially called, gigglingly enough, The Hand Job. “Wait ’till the handjob movie comes out!” Plaza said with a grin. “In that movie, everyone will see. In your face! You don’t even know!”