Read Evelyn Waugh’s Nasty Response to ‘Catch 22′

When a young publicist at Simon & Schuster sent Evelyn Waugh a copy of Joseph Heller’s Catch-22 back in 1961, his response was a lot less enthusiastic than what she was hoping for. Among the zingers in his scathing response to one the greatest literary works of the 20th century: “I am sorry that the book fascinates you so much. It has many passages quite unsuitable to a lady’s reading. It suffers not only from indelicacy but from prolixity. It should be cut by about a half. In particular the activities of ‘Milo’ should be eliminated or greatly reduced.”

But wait! That’s not all! He then goes on to write, “You are mistaken in calling it a novel. It is a collection of sketches — often repetitious — totally without structure.”

What do you think? Is this as vicious as what the Brideshead Revisited author had to say about Marcel Proust in our roundup of the harshest author-on-author insults in history? Before you decide, head over to Letters of Note to read the full text of his letter, including the blurb that he so generously offers up.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 18,709 other followers