Ranking Musician Tribute Songs from Best to Worst

We were intrigued to hear that Patti Smith’s new record Banga contains a track called “This Is the Girl,” which is apparently a tribute to none other than Amy Winehouse. We haven’t heard the song yet — if you have, do feel free to let us know in the comments whether it’s any good or not — but either way, it’s the latest in a music industry tradition: that of musicians writing songs for their deceased counterparts. Of course, some such songs are more successful than others — and so, here’s a selection that spans the spectrum of good to bad. Guess which end “I’ll Be Missing You” comes at!

Stevie Wonder — ”Sir Duke”

If you look up “exuberant” in an online dictionary, you may well find a link to the above video, Stevie Wonder’s joyous tribute to Duke Ellington — who died two years before this song was released — and the other “pioneers that time will not allow us to forget.” You can feel it all over, people.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Brand new track from Killer Mike called "R.A.P. Music" is a tribute to all kinds of African-American music & artists. It names influences as diverse as Miles Davis, Nina Simone, Muddy Waters and Mahilia Jackson, amongst others. A really good song from a record that's full of them. Check it out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V6G1cLYoivQ

How can you forget Bob Dylan's "Blind Willie McTell"? Once you hear it you never will, it's hauntingly beautiful.

I'll have to second Larry's vote for "Nightshift" and add Diana Ross' beautiful "Missing You," also about Marvin Gaye.

added for the part 2 list - Leonard Cohen's Chelsea Hotel #2 about Janis Joplin.

I have a soft spot for The Commodore's "Nightshift", their tribute to Marvin Gaye and Jackie Wilson.

Elton John "Empty Garden"= John Lennon

Oooh, if we're talking about Jeff Buckley Tributes how about To The Sea by Mark Eitzel?

I'll Be Missing You is even worse when you realise that Puff Daddy didn't even write his own verses. Sauce Money wrote them and not even about Biggie, he wrote them about his mother. Nothing about that song was written with Biggie in mind.

Rufus Wainwright tribute to Jeff Buckley - "Memphis Skyline" - should have a place at this rank.

A great tribute is PJ Harvey's Memphis,a tribute to Jeff Buckley