TV’s All-Time Greatest Writers

If you shut off Girls this past Sunday with a sigh of relief, you’re not alone. Between May and June we’ve all endured an emotionally exhausting line-up of season finales (not to mention penultimate and triumvirate finales), and frankly this week was a nice, quiet reprieve. Sort of. Knowing what’s ahead, it’s been impossible to get too comfortable. New seasons of Breaking Bad and Louie are slowly approaching, we can’t not watch Weeds‘ last season, there’s catching up to do on Bunheads, and of course this Sunday, Sorkin is back. So, in an exercise to get the juices flowing, we’ve decided to round up the writers we believe to be most responsible for putting us in this stressful state of TV addiction, starting with the king of TV confabulation himself.

Aaron Sorkin

“It’s not intelligence. It’s my phonetic ability to imitate the sound of intelligence.” — Sorkin on writing smart people)

Highlights: Sports Night (1998-00), The West Wing (1999-03), Studio 60 (2006-07), and HBO’s forthcoming The Newsroom. (You also may have heard of his films A Few Good Men, The Social Network, and Moneyball.)

Influence: He’s widely lauded for breaking long-form conversation on TV (see the “walk and talk”) and “Sorkinism” — a dramatized version of American politics and media that usually yields some greater truth. Any entertaining repartee characterized by the above is often referred to as “Sorkinesque.”

Supplemental reading: See @sorkinese, “A daily elocution safari with the wit & wisdom of Aaron Sorkin characters.”

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Agree with everyone who pointed out the ridiculousness of claiming this is an "all-time" list of writers and leaves off anyone before 2000. Seriously, Michelle, learn some TV history. The writers you cite always credit their forebears.

David E Kelley: LA Law (emmy), Doogie Howser (NPH!), Picket Fences (emmy), Chicago Hope (emmy), Ally McBeal (emmy), The Practice (emmy), Boston Public, Boston Legal, Harry's Law, Mystery Alaska and Lake Placid. Duh.

Onoohnoo nailed it with John Swartzwelder, also maybe Sam Simon, George Meyer, Greg Daniels, Conan O'Brien, Bill Oakley, Josh Weinstein, Al Jean, Mike Reiss (I could go on forever)...not having any writers from the classic era of the Simpsons feels wrong. In conclusion, John Swartzwelder is amazing.

So Rod Serling, Matt Weiner, Paddy Chayefsky and David Milch aren't on the list. But Dan Harmon is? Are you kidding me?

I'd add Gene Roddenberry, Lorne Michaels, David Burrows and the teams at M*A*S*H and um, Monty Python?

I'd echo everyone who's said this is a great list of writers, but it really misses out on anyone who's not (a) had a show on recently, or (b) American - where are the great British writers like Russell T Davies, Steven Moffatt, Paul Abbott, Jimmy McGovern, Lynda La Plante and, of course, Dennis Potter? On the American side, I think J Michael Straczynski and Steven Bochco really deserve a place here - not only are they bloody great writers, but they really pioneered the TV story arc with Babylon 5 and Murder One, when the received wisdom was still very much that television audiences didn't have the wit or the patience to follow ongoing narrative from week to week. And Jane Espenson should be here just for sheer amazingness.

No Jason Katims? Seriously? from writing on My So -Called Life, to Roswell to FNL to Parenthood. JASON KATIMS I LOVE YOU.

Besides Rod Serling, Paddy Chayevsky, and David E. Kelley, I'd also have included Nigel Neale, Reginald Rose, and Dennis Potter. I'd even include Jackson Gillis over a lot of the people on this list......

She's never been a big up-front name, but every time I see Jane Espenson attached to something, I know the dialogue will be awesome. Just a few things she's written for: Buffy, Torchwood, Game of Thrones, Once Upon a Time, Warehouse 13, Battlestar Galactica, Gilmore Girls, Angel, Firefly, Ellen... For a male-heavy list, it would be nice for a brilliant female writer to be acknowledged who isn't Tina Fey.

What a phenomenally ignorant little girl you must be. This isn't even a well-chosen list of people who wrote TV shows that aired in the last 15 years.

She probably also thinks Lebron James is the greatest basketball player of all-time.

Other than the absence of Matt Weiner and Shawn Ryan and Graham Yost and David Milch and a few others, this is a decent list of current writers for American TV. But if you're not going to include Rod Serling, Larry Gelbart, Paddy Chayefsky, Norman Lear, Steven Bochco, Carl Reiner or James L. Brooks or anybody who has written for British TV, you just don't want to include the "All-Time" in the headline. If one of your criteria is "Influence" and you don't list *any* those guys... Yeah. Just delete the "All-Time" and maybe make it "Favorite" and this is a fine gallery.

and of course Serling and Chayefksy et al. This list is embarrassing. I understand TV is great now. I love LOUIE, but come on, it has like 12 hours of content. Do a tiny bit of research.

The list should be retitled "Top 10 TV Writers from the past 10 years (or who have a least had success in the past 10) and are still relevant to the conversation with cult television shows that flirted outside of the mainstream and who's name isn't Matt Weiner or Steven Moffat"

Norman Lear, Carl Reiner, Mel Brooks, James L. Brooks, Steven Bochco, David Milch, and a whole bunch of other great writers who worked before 2001 say this list was written by a child.

Michelle, I believe you are in dire need of a lesson regarding the meaning of the term "all-time".

after reading this, rod serling turned to paddy chayefsky and said "would you like to hit them with the flame thrower or should i?" "let matt wiener handle it," chayefsky replied, "he's young."

Really really surprised that David E Kelley isn't here. I love Louis ck but I don't feel he has done enough to make him one of the 10 greatest.

Seconded for Bryan Fuller. And, I know they're not the most popular, but Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cruse deserve some recognition. Sure, they had no idea where they were going with "Lost," but they handled it and presented it as if they knew exactly what was going on...and that's the important part. John Schwartzhelder, David Silverman, Brad Bird -- basically the original team behind The Simpsons. Finally, this seems more like a list of greatest creators/showrunners. Which is all right, too.

Steven Moffat (Doctor Who and Sherlock)

To say "all-time greatest tv writers" and not include Rod Sterling is a grave oversight.

Bryan Fuller deserves a spot for his creativity in whimisical, vaguely fantastic shows like Pushing Daisies and Wonderfalls. The characters were quick and charming without falling into cutesy.