The Most Underrated Guitarists in Rock ‘n’ Roll

We were rather chuffed to note the presence of a new record by Ry Cooder in the release schedule for this week. We’ve long been fans of Cooder’s work, both because he’s a great songwriter and because he’s a fantastic guitarist — we’re constantly disappointed to find him missing from the Greatest Guitarist Ever lists that crop up from time to time. (And his version of “Cancion Mixteca” from Paris, Texas is still just the most sublime thing ever.) Anyway, he’s far from the only one constantly overlooked for these “honors,” such as they are, so here are some other thoroughly underrated guitarists from the world of rock ‘n’ roll — your suggestions, as ever, are entirely welcome.

Nick Drake

The general tendency is to associate “great guitarist” with “flashy solo skills,” which means that some pretty impressive rhythm guitarists and/or accompanists get forgotten. Take, for instance, Nick Drake, whose intricate finger-picking parts — often in strange time signatures and/or with curious offbeat rhythms — are just as demanding as getting the intro to “Sweet Child O’ Mine” sounding right.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

So glad to see someone working to bring Rowland S. Howard the posthumous props he was denied during his lifetime. Still can't figure out how Nick Cave become a household name when his more talented band mate was overlooked for 25 years...

Also Jonny Greenwood of Radiohead?

Second St. Vincent and Rick McCollum! Would also add Mark Kozelek of solo, Red House Painters and Sun Kil Moon.

Jamie West-Oram - The Fixx

Duane Denison, Jesus Lizard

Page Hamilton-Helmet Rick McCollum-Afghan Whigs

See Prince's version of While My Guitar Gently Weeps from a Rock n Roll Hall of Fame ceremony.

What about the Isley Brothers? I'm not sure his first name... but on Whos' That Lady and all their songs-- he's the best! They always cut off the end of the song when it's on the radio and that part is just screaming good.

All these comments about other guitarists...Did you not read the title? Andy Summer, Malcolm Young, Johnny Marr...these are all well known and heralded guitarists. We're discussing 'Underrated'.

Joey Santiago. Ernest Ranglin

Annie Clark a.ka. St. Vincent.

+lindsey buckingham. the man can play. and he's an incredible finger-picker. +porl thompson (formerly of the cure)- fearless, gorgeous, creative guitar playing! listen to 'from the edge of the deep green sea'. +nels cline. his solo on wilco's 'impossible germany' is probably my favorite guitar solo of all time. +john frusciante. genius. that is all. the inclusion of prince on this list confuses me. anyone with any sense in their head and taste in music knows he's one of the greatest guitar players of our time.

I second Ivan: Nels Cline! I didn't get it until I saw him live and now I'm a total convert.

JEFF BUCKLEY. amazing voice, too.

Roland S. Howard. YES! Joni Mitchell Steve Severin Steve Jones Poison Ivy - she created the sound of The Cramps on one string. That's integrity!

Another list that has omitted oft-overlooked guitar greats like Alex Lifeson, Robertson/Gorham, and Mike McCready for more random hipster indie fare. PJ Harvey? Really?!?

FACT: No of these people can guitar better than me ;)

Black Francis of the Pixies.

At first I was going to share this with my 17 year old son who is already playing professionally. But this list is seriously lacking. The time span is very narrow. Even for this small timespan that the author narrowly limits, himself their were many underrated guitarist who are better than those on this list.

Got no arguments with this list, and you could have easily added a dozen more, One artist in particular who is an almost unknown to the public at large is Tommy Tedesco, the most recorded Guitarist in history, a session guy who was sought out by way to many people/bands/movie and TV soundtracks to list here...Guarantee you have heard him, just never knew it was him...truely an unsung hero in the music/guitar world.

Joe Baiza, of the SST label band, Saccharine Trust, is the best, most unjustly ignored guitarist west of the Mississippi. And Nels Cline, (famous from Wilco but lots of other work).

Mark: I agree about SM. His style was similar to the great Steve Cropper's. Especially on "Pale Blue Eyes".

John McGeoch (RIP) of Magazine (The Correct Use of Soap) Siouxie & the Banshees (Kaleidoscope), and later incarnations of PiL (no disrespect to Keith Levene).

Prince definitely. He has done so many more amazing guitar tracks than 'Purple Rain'. The 'Sign O' The Times' album has incredible guitar throughout. The other one overlooked is Kurt Cobain - the 'non' guitar solos on 'In Utero' reveal an ability that Cobian probably wanted to hide. I think deep down he knew his Jimmy Page licks. The guy could play guitar and with great imagination for the unusual. Otherwise I agree with the guy who earlier mentioned Roland from Tears For Fears.

Not a bad list...but Prince? Really? Nick McCabe from the Verve, Johnny Marr, Richard Thompson, Bernard Butler, John Martyn? You're gonna need a bigger list.

Bill Nelson - best known as the driving force behind Be Bop Deluxe, his solo outings (to me) have eclipsed all of the BBD stuff. Never content to stand still (and a multi-instrumentalist) his work covers a lot of ground. Unbelievably prolific! His site is Dreamsville. Robert Fripp - most known for his leadership of King Crimson, but his ethereal soundscape cds are worth checking out. Phil Manzanera-guitarist for Roxy Music, has lent his talents to many other projects including Pink Floyd.

Todd Rundgren. The most underrated Renaissance man of music-- genius composer, producer, vocalist, synth player, theremin player, and, oh, yeah, GUITARIST! Check out the scorching solos on "The Last Ride," "Death of Rock and Roll," "Black Maria," and the very early "Broke Down and Busted" for some evidence thereof.

Ira Kaplan, Yo La Tengo - hands down David Rawlings - is he underrated?

Although known primarily as a singer and keyboardist, Steve Winwood is an amazing guitarist too. Check out Dear Mr. Fantasy.

I don't think Paul Simon gets recognized for his guitar skills as much as his songwriting, but his guitar playing is brilliant.

Sterling Morrison, hands down.

Jon Herington, lead guitarist with Steely Dan since 2000 and solo artist in his own right, is phenomenal and not always mentioned by people outside the inner fan fold. In their live shows he has to play up to and beyond standards of a long list of legendary guitar soloists & he totally exceeds expectations.

You're missing Louise Post of Veruca Salt. She rips out solos on practically every track on American Thighs. Amazing.

Since this website skews alternative/indie, I'm not surprised by these picks, most of which I disagree with. However, you're 100% on the money with Nick Drake and Richard Lloyd. Drake has played some of the most beautifully, melancholy melodic guitar that's ever been recorded. And Lloyd is amazing. His solo on "Elevation" is like a Bowery version of Lindsey Buckingham (another underrated guitarist). And his riffs on "Foxhole" and "Ain't That Nothin'" are up there with the best of Keith Richards and Malcolm Young. While Television would be one of the main influences on what came to be known as alternative, Lloyd's riffs are pure hard rock swagger. More Ace Frehley than Johnny Marr. Other underrated guitarists include Joe Walsh, Duck Dharma, Billy Duffy, Otis Rush, Mike Bloomfield, Paul Kossoff, Danny Kirwan, Will Sergeant, Rory Gallagher, Mike McCready, Luther Allison, Alex Lifeson, and a whole load of others. If some of these names are unfamiliar to you, go on youtube, particularly Bloomfield's work on "East/West".

Andy Gill- Gang of four J Mascis- Dinosaur Jr Keith Levene- Pil

Maurice Deebank of Felt. "The World is as Soft as Lace" is a good starting point for his filligreed beauty...

Glenn (2 "n"s) Phillips from Atlanta, Georgia - one of the best I've heard. (Glenn Phillips Band, Hampton Grease Band)

Joey Santiago of the Pixies. Maybe not technically the most amazing virtuoso, but his surf-inspired trickery gave way to so many imitators but no duplicators. Plus, on their first reunion tour, he was killing those Vamos (Surfer Rosa) solos (like with a beer bottle and shit). Love that guy.

Karl Precoda when he was electrifying the Dream Syndicate

No David Bowie? Not only was he a fantastic rhythm player, he played all the lead guitar on Diamond Dogs ... amazing stuff.

Daniel Lanois - especially on the pedal steel.

I'd add Danny Gatton to the list. What he could do with that Telecaster - guess it's probably not 'rock', but still...

Jonny Marr, the melodic font of every Smiths tune - c'mon.....