Bombs Away: 12 of Film’s Most Welcome Failures

We try not to make a habit of cheering failure (really, honestly, promise, we don’t), but we couldn’t help getting a little warm and runny inside when Battleship laid a big egg at the beginning of the summer, since the movie beat is filled with tales of great movies that no one sees, and terrible turkeys that make a fortune. But occasionally, people just don’t go see a barking dog of a picture, and that can be good for all of us — not just because time isn’t wasted and incompetence isn’t rewarded, but because Hollywood is a town that takes its cues from what does well, so when a bad idea fails, more are less likely to follow. So today, in honor of Battleship’s DVD/Blu-ray release tomorrow, we’ll take a look at a dozen big-time bombs, and what the movie industry did or didn’t learn from them.

TOTAL COST: $319 million
GROSS*: $65 million
LESSON: Sure, there have been stranger sources for feature films, but still: who thinks it’s a good idea to start turning board games into movies? The desperate suits at the studios, that’s who, who are so obsessed with the notion of pre-selling movies based on familiar “brands” that, basically, as long as a movie is based on something you’ve heard of, they’ll throw money at it. In the case of Battleship, a game centered (when you get right down to it) on putting pegs into a board, the filmmakers were clearly challenged for cinematic elements, so they adopted a classic Hollywood solution: steal from somewhere else. In this case, the final Battleship film ended up an alien invasion tale with a suspicious resemblance to the Transformers movies.
LEARNED? Poor Taylor Kitsch (who also had the misfortune of starring in the spring’s other big money-loser, John Carter) probably won’t get too many more leading roles, but in terms of the lesson that should’ve been learned, i.e., don’t turn board games into movies — well, we’ll have to get back to you on that after the Adam Sandler Candyland movie comes out.

*all grosses domestic, and yes, fine, it made a ridiculous amount of money overseas, where they like watching shit blow up real good even more than we do.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 18,666 other followers