10 Great Books That Should Be Movies

Hollywood has always looked to literature for inspiration and adaptation fodder, but these days, it seems more likely than not that any given new film will be based on a book (or be a sequel or a superhero movie, but let’s set that aside). Not that that’s a bad thing — we’re looking forward to Cloud Atlas, On the Road, and The Perks of Being a Wallflower as much as the next guy. Still, we’re baffled at some of the books that, for whatever reason, haven’t yet been snapped up by the Hollywood machine. After the jump, we’ve put together a list of novels that we’d love to see hit the big screen — click through to check out our picks and add your own wish list in the comments!

One Hundred Years of Solitude, Gabriel García Márquez

We think this novel — one of the most beloved books of the 20th century — would make a beautiful, lush, frankly magical film. We say that because it’s a beautiful, lush, frankly magical book. But unfortunately (for us) García Márquez has never agreed to sell the rights. Maybe he has something even better in mind.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
matthewKowalsk5 5 pts

The Hollywood formula is a dead body slowly bobbing in the water waiting for the new wave of independents to circle its blood leaking corpse.  My name is Matt Kowalski my email is rapidmak@yahoo.com  Anyone know a good route to secure rights to a treasure that they would rather see through the eyes of a filmmaker untethered by the Hollywood machine?  Throw me a bone if so.  I'm an award winning independent and damn near every one of these books is locked in "option limbo".  Thanks.

special topics in calamity physics!

I pray that García Márquez never gives in to Hollywood. Perhaps it would be a "beautiful, lush, frankly magical" film, but it will never come close to the imagery that he has created in my imagination. Plus, with so many rich characters, Hollywood would never do them all justice and no one wants to see 12 hour movies.

I just read Secret History for the 4th time, and thought yet again that it would make a great movie. Didn't Paltrow's brother have the rights at one point? Tartt's second (and sadly, only other) book, The Little Friend, would be even easier to make into a great little thriller. And Black Hole--YES! One of the best graphic novel's I've read. I think it would make a great HBO show..

I have always felt that Kevin Spacey needs to play Larry in Carol Sheild's Larry's Party. I affectionately call Shipping News, American Beauty and Larry's Party Kevin Spacey's "Loser Triad". I think in the right hands it would be brilliant.

The Magus by Fowles would make a great movie. So would Embers by Sandor Marai. Revolutionary Road is one of the best novels ever written but was difficult to adapt because it's hard to convey the protagonists' inner dialogue onto the screen. Last, but not least, enough with DFW. A talentless, overpraised, postmodern hack.

Thomas Berger's Killing Time (about a lovable mass murderer who kills out of pity) or Regiment of Women (could be the best sex role reversal movie ever); Walker Percy's The Moviegoer or Lancelot; John Barth's The Floating Opera; Peter De Vries's The Blood of the Lamb or Let Me Count the Ways; Robert Plunket's My Search For Warren Harding; John Fowles's The Magus needs to be re-done; Jim Bouton's Ball Four. John Dickson Carr's The Murder of Sir Edmund Godfrey (the best piece of historical detection ever). Mark Twain's The Mysterious Stranger. Some of these, like Ball Four, would be better as a Cable series probably.

China Miéville's novel "Un Lun Dun" would be a great Miyazaki movie -- strong female lead vs the Smog, a pet milk carton named Curdle. Yeah!

I always thought that Leonard Cohen's "The Favourite Game" would - in the right hands, of course - make a fantastic movie ... great coming of age tale, and some of the dialogue is hilarious. I also second the vote for "His Dark Materials", and add to that the "Lemony Snicket" series, and the rest of the "Spyderwick Chronicles" ... not sure how these franchises lost momentum, but at this point, most of the actors would have to be re-cast as some of them are far too old to pass as children now.

Making a feature film is a multimillion dollar enterprise that takes many years to realize. The first step is for a producer to secure the rights. After that there has to be a script created and a breakdown, shooting schedule and budget made as well. Talent needs to be cast. Then you have to make the thing. We are currently going through this process with "Marlowe", a film based on my 1988 stage play MARLOWE: An Elizabethan Tragedy, and another to be produced in 2014 or 2015 based upon my novel "The Shenandoah Spy". Since I own all the rights, the process is a bit easier, but the rest of it requires patience and constant application to realize a final product. It is much more complicated than just publishing a book. Also much more expensive.

NONE of these books should be made into movies!! And @brint thank you for saying this so succintly, so perfectly.

Generally I'm thrilled when a great novel doesn't get squeezed into a two-hour Hollywood movie. But I'm stunned that Carl Hiaason's hilarious and angry "Tourist Season" hasn't made its way to the screen yet. Tommy Lee Jones woulda killed as Skip Wiley 20 years ago.

Agree: "Geek Love" "A Confederacy of Dunces" Would add: "Zeroville" - Steve Erickson "Idoru" - William Gibson "Anansi Boys " - Neil Gaiman

Ok: - Unbroken - The Devil in the White City (Apparently the rights are owned by Leonardo Di Caprio...so we'll see) - Empire of the Summer Moon (At least part of this story should be told. The early third is my vote.) - Shockwave: Countdown to Hiroshima- no one has told the full story of the bombing of Hiroshima in film as far as I am aware. This would be gripping and sad and harrowing and timely in some fashion. - I also vote for a re-do of His Dark Materials, only this time with some competent people involved... - The Sisters Brothers - The Yiddish Policemen's Union - Y The Last Man - Snow Crah by Neal Stephenson HBO Mini Series special request- The Looming Towers. Oh that would be so good. Get on it Hollywood!

I would love to see Paul Thomas Anderson adapt a Thomas Pynchon novel- Gravity's Rainbow in particular. @Rachel, I would :)

Would you watch the Infinite Jest movie even if you knew it would kill you? :)

Would you watch the Infinite Jest movie even if you knew it kill you? :)

The Iowa Baseball Confederacy by WP Kinsella. If they make it, we will come.

Theyve been trying to get Black Hole made for a while now i think at one point David Fincher was attached.

a good day to die, by jim harrison. i've always thought that it would be make a great movie.

i've always wondered why they haven't attempted house of leaves, although, to be honest, i'm not exactly eager to have it ruined by the hollywood formula. i just think that placed in the right hands, it would make an interesting psych thriller. maybe fincher could make it work.

Paradise Lost. Though it could be amazing or awful. Hollywood is trying, but the fact they want to cast one of the guys from The Hangover as Satan and have it in 3D suggests to me they are going more down the route of Clash of the Titans... But it could be so good with the right team (Peter Jackson & WETA?), an amazing actor as Satan and of it kept some of the epic Miltonian language. Who wouldn't go and see Angels armed with flaming swords at war?

Rendevous With Rama comes to mind;Fincher and M.Freeman have talked about it,so who knows...

great books are great because they're books. turning them into movies is like turning chinese food into pizza.

"Blood Meridian" Cormac McCarthy, has been "in development" for years, but its hard to imagine it coming to the screen. Everyone is either spooked by the violence or else tempted to make it into a western/slash/slasher flick, and what would be the point. I've never quite understood the insistance that some of the gorier scenes have to be displayed onscreen, or why the Judge couldn't be the character in the book, and not some garalous, serial-killer-trope.