10 Novels to Replace ‘Catcher In The Rye’ as the Perfect Teen Book

Last Friday, Jessica Roake over at Slate lamented the fall of Holden Caulfield in the esteem of modern teenagers — “The problem is that Catcher in the Rye is no longer a book for cool high school students,” she writes. “Catcher in the Rye is a book for cool high school teachers.” A host of factors have added to the books current lack of cool, the most important probably being its ubiquitousness on modern high school syllabi — how can something truly feel underground, transformative, if your teachers are assigning it?

“The perfect teenage book should feel like it’s being passed around secretly, its message too raw and powerful for adults to understand,” Roake explains. “It should inspire highlighting and ponderous margin notes that embarrass you 20 years later. Most of all, it should feel like it’s speaking directly to you, and only you, even if everyone else in your class is working on the same essay question.” We totally concur, and after the jump, we’ve put forward ten novels that we think might just have the chops to replace our beloved Catcher in our collective teenage imaginations. But then again, maybe nothing will ever replace it. Click through to check out our list, and if you don’t see your favorite, add and argue in the comments.

Black Swan Green, David Mitchell

Roake suggests Black Swan Green, the semi-autobiographical story of a sensitive young boy — stutterer, poet — growing up in England, and we agree wholeheartedly. Not only is this book impeccably written and rather moving (whether you’re a floundering teenager or no), but as former teenagers ourselves, we recognize that pretentious joy of drawling “Oh, David Mitchell? Yes, you’ve read Cloud Atlas, but how about Black Swan Green?” Taking in his entire oeuvre wouldn’t hurt them either.

Filed Under:


Nothing will ever replace Cather in the Rye. Alot of kids are stupid these days and quite frankly I can better relate to the teacher assigning Catcher than I can to my classmates. And isnt that just like Holden? Holden liked Mr.Antolini, not Stradlater. Not Ackley. Catcher in the Rye isnt a "secret" "cool" teenage pass-around. Its a map for the unheard, the misunderstood, and the unwanted. No matter what age. Holden may have a literal age of 17. But Holden is much more than a character. Holden is a state of mind. Holden is theory, he is an element. That element can live in anyone. That element has no age, nor can ever be replaced. Youre right. This isnt a book for "cool kids." But that was never its intention. Your listed books could be "books for cool kids." But thats not what Catcher is supposed to be. In fact, it is the exact opposite. It is for the misfits, the outcasts, the critical intellectuals, the sequestered.


@AmandaCaulfield  I understand what you're saying, but doesn't everyone feel alienation like that at some point? I don't really think it's a secret club of people who relate to Caulfield.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 18,350 other followers