10 TV Shows Better Than the Books They Were Based On

So if you’re celebrating your birthday today, you share it with Charlaine Harris, she who gave the world the insanely successful Sookie Stackhouse novels and thus, indirectly, also the joys of True Blood. As you’ve probably noted if you read Flavorwire at all regularly, we’re borderline obsessed with True Blood, and its success got us thinking of the slew of TV shows based on books that have emerged in the last few years — and, in particular, those that have defied the old adage that the book is always better. We’ve collected a bunch of shows that we reckon have transcended their literary origins — can you think of any other shows that are better than the books they’re based on? (And before you go all crazy in the comments, a disclaimer: we said “better.” We’re not necessarily claiming the books in question are bad — although some most definitely are — just that the TV series they spawned was/is better. OK? Carry on.)

True Blood

So, yes, we’ll be honest and admit straight out that we’re huge suckers for True Blood the TV show in all its absurd, camp glory — the accents, the supernatural silliness, the blood-soaked Lilith running around naked. We love it so much, in fact, that Harris’s books can’t help but pale in comparison, especially as they kill off our favorite character (we’re not saying who, in case you haven’t read them) relatively early on. The fact that Harris’s prose is kinda horrible — a problem we’ll encounter repeatedly on this list — doesn’t help matters any.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
GRRM 5 pts

Either you are high or haven't read a Song of Ice and FIre. Any differences between tv show and the book, the book version wins. There is so much more backstory and characters that we don't get to see in the show. Plus the tv show makes it more light hearted and they have left out some crucial parts. I do not know about a few of the other books on here but ASOIAF is a very successful franchise. You don't even make a vague point to your argument. Don't get me wrong Game of Thrones (show) gets a 10/10 from me but the books are a master piece and the greatest fantasy series of this generation and arguably of all time.

ChrisCopeland 5 pts

True Blood book series are FAR FAR superior to the campy TV show.  There is no question.  If you think the show is better then you never read the books...

Dexter is much better in book form. The TV series is good enough, but becomes cliched in it's story lines.

I admit that A Song of Ice and Fire isn't well written. George R. R. Martin has a problem with reusing the same phrases and his tone is very stilted. Not to mention he over describes EVERYTHING. But the characters are so much more nuanced than in the show. There's so much explanation and backstory, and the plot is so much more intriguing in the novels. I adore the show, and they did a great job with season 1 (though season 2 went off the tracks a bit), so I'd really say it's a draw. Each has it's pros and cons.

ChrisCopeland 5 pts

The books are FAR better then the show so far.  Season 2 of the TV show was a total mess.

@Erica - you're correct, I am clearly not a woman with friends

Wow, hating on SATC hard. You're clearly not a woman with friends.

I loved True Blood Season 1 and was GLAD when they didn't kill off one of the characters that the book did. But that's where it stops. Each season of TB has been worse than the last. I am so disappointed in it. I just can't believe anyone who has watched past season 2 can argue that the series is better than the books. It isn't.

ChrisCopeland 5 pts

Cindy is right. However I disagree... I am not happy they kept the character... his storylines post season one have been a travesty.

I'm with you on the True Blood TV series. Not sure if you've read the entire Sookie Stackhouse series, but they have been going downhill with the latest one (#12) being utter rubbish. (Coming from a fan if the books initially) I don't even think Harris is trying anymore.

ChrisCopeland 5 pts

Books 1 - 7 are far better than the plots they came up with on the show.  I have no idea why they changed anything...

Friday Night Lights is an unbelievably good book. I loved the movie. The TV series is great, but better than the book? Tough call, Tom.

I'm sorry, but no. Game of Thrones (read: A Song of Fire and Ice) is definitely, definitely better in book form. From the link: "The characters are more nuanced in the TV show: Part of the reason it’s hard to get into “Game of Thrones” as a series of novels is the fact that within the first hundred pages, you’ve got it firmly established who the bad guys and the good guys are, and…well…that’s it." What?? Has Dan Seitz read past the first book? I'll give the TV show its due, but there is so much chronology, complexity, and story that people who watch the show are missing out on.

I love GoT season 1 but the show seems more like a softcore porn now. The sex seems while entertaining are just too frequent and the wedding night between daenyris and drago was so poorly done. In the book he showed her respect and care the show he pretty muched raped her.

100% wrong re: Game of Thrones.

dexter is on showtime, not hbo.

Re Dwarf the book is good the show is more fun

I disagree completely about GG. Not that I think the books are any good, but definitely much less hate-worthy than the awful, awful show.

Here, hered Kathleen before I read the entire list. WHAT?! Friday Night Lights? What? They are so different as to be two different genres. You can't even compare. But you are right about M*A*S*H. Love using those star thingies.

Woah what happened here?? I can't speak for all of these books and shows, but in defense of Charlaine Harris--you can't even compare the show to the books. The books are amazing amazing amazing, and this past season of True Blood went so far in a completely different direction than the books that it may have ruined the show. The general plotlines of each season have followed Harris' first couple of books, which is why the show is so good (well that and Alexander Skarsgard!), but Harris is the genius here and straying from that will definitely be detrimental. The books are better.

ChrisCopeland 5 pts

Exactly.  The characters on the show don't even resemble their book characters...  I want QUINN... but of course he will never show up now.

"Pronto" and "Riding the Rap" are both great books featuring Raylen Givens, and both could be handily adapted into films, but the sort-of source of "Justified" is another Elmore Leonard worl, the short story "Fire in the Hole"....

You clearly did not read Game of Thrones.