2013 Grammy Awards: Ranking the Performances from Best to Worst

Well, now. The Grammys. The entire spectacle is like watching a huge whale thrashing ineffectively on a deserted beach, except the whale somehow has an unfathomable supply of money and gets an entire multi-bazillion dollar extravaganza on live TV to demonstrate to the world that it’s a slowly decaying behemoth. And yet we get together to watch them every year, wincing our way through interminable hours of awful award speeches and awful awards because of one thing: the performances — because just occasionally, there might be something good. Was that the case this year? Click through, gentle readers, and find out — we watched the whole damn thing so you don’t have to.

Frank Ocean

OK, so, let’s get the good stuff out of the way first. Even with a strange choice of song (“Forrest Gump”) and a weird, trippy conceptual projection thing that wasn’t quite as cool as its creators might have liked it to be, Ocean was head and shoulders over pretty much every other insufferable wazzock who played this evening. It’s a shame he only warranted one song.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
AliciaZimmey 5 pts

Why were the Alabama Shakes the only nominee for best New Artist that did not warrant a separate performance? They are amazing live. Brittany Howard was on stage for the Levon Helm tribute, and was given approximately 4-6 lines to sing (without her band). They are the only reason I tuned in to this outdated, train wreck of a performance. What a major disappointment.

JeffTweedy 5 pts

I can respect wanting the Grammys to honor Donna Summer and MCA, but completely writing off the Levon Helm tribute as a symptom of "baby boomer-centric white dude aesthetic" is fucking stupid and snark for snark's sake. Combine that with the fact that you seem not to be able to actually rationalize why you picked anything here, or know much about music in general, and that makes you a writer worth ignoring. Here's hoping you eventually grow up from hiding behind catty, ill-informed bullshit as a "voice" and learn how to write. 

mattsg88 9 pts

I like Frank Ocean a lot. And I like "Forrest Gump" a lot. And I was excited to watch the performance, but the sloooooooowwwwwwwweeeeeeeeeedddddd down tempo kind of took all the energy out of the song, the sexuality, and a bit of the groove. 

 

And when it comes to fun., I'm sure two years ago you were proclaiming how great they were. And then they get big, get success, and suddenly, Oh la de da. JillShirley had a good point, that you're basically being the worst kind of hipsters.

 

I look forward to not reading any of your write-ups when the new Vampire Weekend record comes up. 

thawking 23 pts moderator

 mattsg88 Nah, sorry, you're off target here. I've never proclaimed "how great" fun. were, for the simple reason that they have never been great. I've defended Vampire Weekend in the past and will continue to do so if the new record is good.

JillShirley 5 pts

Here is a truth: everyone is going gaga over Frank Ocean because of his coming out. Not because of his music. He's not doing anything different/better than any other R&B star out there. And yeah, he was definitely pitchy in that performance.

 

It would be really nice if you guys could get someone to do music articles that wasn't an insufferable hipster who looks down his nose at any and all popular music. If it's not so f'ing underground you're almost in China it seems to be considered crap on this website. Every time I click on a music article, I'll have maybe heard of one, MAYBE two of the people you're talking about, and the people you are talking about are ... okay.

thawking 23 pts moderator

 JillShirley Here is a truth: that's your opinion.

Claredelune 5 pts

 JillShirley Hear, hear! My sentiments exactly JillShirley, so glad someone else finds the music commentary on this site (this article included) so full of hipster pretension it's unbearable.

thawking 23 pts moderator

ClaredeluneJillShirley Sigh. Here's some interesting reading on the word "pretentious" (also applies to "hipster", a term that's basically useless in 2013 and says as much about the person using it as it does about whoever they're accusing of being such a thing): http://becausegoodbye.tumblr.com/post/42707760044/on-the-word-pretentious

mattsg88 9 pts

 thawking  Claredelune  JillShirley I think this guy has some good points on what gives hipsters a bad name: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f3xe-Wxio1o

 

You know that book, "Stuff White People Like", where the author distinguishes between like Brooklynites and the bad kind of white people (gun-totin' Southerners, mostly)? I tink there's something similar within the hipster scene. And the worst kind of hipsters are the ones who like things ironically or once they become popular instantly hate them. 

 

Flavorwire, I think, straddles the line between being hip and being the worst kind of hipster. I think it's a valid criticism, but one that's thrown around too much that it's in danger of losing pertinence. 

thawking 23 pts moderator

 mattsg88  Claredelune  JillShirley Honestly I don't think the word "hipster" has any currency these days. If there was ever a hipster "scene", it was around Williamsburg in the early '00s, and that scene has long since disappeared (and, indeed, was long gone by the time I got to NYC). These days the word is shorthand for a whole bunch of pop cultural stereotypes that are rarely reflected in reality, and as a pejorative, it generally means "I don't agree with your opinion and/or you think you're too cool for your own good" (see the lovely JillShirley's comments above for a perfecte example.)

Claredelune 5 pts

 thawking  mattsg88  Claredelune  JillShirley Ok, I withdraw the term "hipster" since apparently it's causing a problem and a distraction from what I actually wanted to say. I was annoyed by commentary and let my annoyance get the better of my vocabulary. 

That being said, I maintain that in many of the music articles on this site there is a certain snobbery that seems to short-hand large swaths of music into the category of "only-stupid-people-could-possibly-like-this."  Which I find both obnoxious and simplistic.  Much as you seem to fine my use of the term "hipster."

thawking 23 pts moderator

Claredelunemattsg88JillShirleyHmmm, yes, OK, point taken. Here's the thing, though: there is so much amazing culture and music out there, and I guess I get frustrated that the music industry still wants to ignore it all in favor of the likes of the acts highlighted at the Grammys, to perpetuate the same narrow view of commercially palatable pop culture that's been served up to the public incessantly over the last 30-40 years or so. I appreciate it's prob utopianism to hope it might ever be different, but I also think that the public is far more open to culture than one might expect, and that it's worth trying to write about acts that mightn't get a heap of publicity elsewhere - after all, what's the point of writing about the Rolling Stones again? What you call snobbery I call enthusiasm for new sounds and horizons, I guess. Still, I appreciate that it's a fine line between being enthusiastic about one's own passions and dismissive of others' - I rarely set out to do the latter, and I do hope it doesn't come across that way. (Unless we're describing fun., in which all bets are off.)

mattsg88 9 pts

 thawking  Claredelune  JillShirley "Hey an award!  

 

...Aww a Grammy."

 

[Chucks it back.]

DumbDomme 5 pts

I saw Frank Ocean at the top of the list and assumed the it was ordered worst to best. Tom, did you miss the fact that he was off key almost the entire song? When he wasn't sharp or flat, he was on the wrong note entirely!

 

His performance was terrible. That, coupled with your observations that it was a "strange choice of song" accompanied by a projection thing that "wasn’t quite as cool" as it was supposed to be, what, exactly, made his performance the best?

 

So, his performance was the best because he wasn't an "insufferable wazzock"?

 

I don't mind some snark, but howabout a teeny bit of meaningful commentary?

thawking 23 pts moderator

 DumbDomme It was the best because, y'know, it was better than all the others.

DumbDomme 5 pts

 thawking  No, I don't know that it was better than the others. I was kinda hoping you'd explain why it was better.. y'know, since you ranked them and all.

 

Perhaps you should reconsider the title of the piece... maybe "Tom Shits on Things (In No Particular Order)."

thawking 23 pts moderator

DumbDommeOK, apologies for the sarcasm, but the tone of this comments section occasionally gets to me. (See your fellow commenters above, to whom I'm apparently an insufferable hipster for being interested in music outside the top 40 and for liking Frank Ocean [but only because he's bi, apparently]). If you're genuinely interested in my opinion, here it is: Ocean's *was* a relatively lackluster performance, as you correctly point out, but it was the best of a bad bunch. I'd take a singer who's somewhat off key — the poor guy was nervous as hell — but actually puts some measure of genuine heart and emotion into their performance over the sort of horrible soulless big-budget backslapping extravaganzas that characterized the rest of the evening. Ocean's song didn't reach the heights he's capable of reaching, and wasn't necessarily amazing by objective standards, but given that the premise of the piece was to rank the performances from best to worst, it was better than anything else on offer – which is as much an indictment on the whole sorry spectacle as anything else.

 

orlando212 6 pts

 thawking  DumbDomme Now THERE'S an analysis that merits reading.  THawking: why couldn't the rest of the post have these insights?  Reading your list made me feel like I was reading a post from Buzzfeed.  No one cares about your comments because they're YOURS; we can about them because they are (hopefully and potentially) insightful.

thawking 23 pts moderator

 orlando212  DumbDomme  This is probably beyond the scope of the comment section, but I'd be happy to answer your question. Email me: tom at flavorpill dot com.