• Flavorwire is part of the Flavorpill network
  • City Guides:
  • New York
  • San Francisco
  • Chicago
  • London
  • More from Flavorpill:
  • Daily Dose
  • Earplug
  • Artkrush
  • Boldtype
  • ThumbnailSartorial Showdown: Figure Skater Johnny Weir vs. Lady Gaga »
  • ThumbnailMagnum Photo Archive On the Move »
  • ThumbnailDaily Dose Pick: Brian Alfred »

Flavorwire

  • Follow us
  • RSS
  • Flavorpill on Twitter
  • Flavorpill on Facebook
  • Flickr: Flavorpill's Photostream
MusicCommentary Pitchfork
The Pitchfork 500: Obscure Enough For You?
8:53 am Thursday Dec 4, 2008 by Doug Schrashun

Pitchfork released The Pitchfork 500: Our Guide to the Greatest Songs from Punk to the Present a few weeks ago, and it’s designed to be a perfect argument starter. No matter how you feel about Pitchfork (“where else would I get all my Beach House news?”, “not emo enough!”), their choices for this list are sure to raise some eyebrows.

From the over-abundance of ’70s reggae and ’90s dance tracks to a relatively lackluster showing for hip-hop, there are any number of battlegrounds among these 500 songs. For now, though, we’ll stick to one particular quibble — Pitchfork’s enduring tendency to arbitrarily over promote obscure music.

We think they might do it just to make us feel stupid.

After the jump are five songs that sent our obscure-o-meter especially deep into the red.

Vic Godard and the Subway Sect – “Parallel Lines”
First off, there’s no clip for the song on YouTube, nor is it playable from Last FM, which in this day and age pretty much means it doesn’t exist. The band was tied to both Malcolm McLaren and Bernie Rhodes, and sounds like a likely John Peel favorite, but wasn’t the whole idea of ’70s punk was that hundreds of songs exactly this good existed?

Felt – “Primitive Painters”
Seems like an excuse to slip a second Liz Fraser vocal on to the 500 without raising the specter of the instant list credibility killing “too Cocteau Twins heavy” tag. Sneaky move, Pitchfork.

Omni Trio – “Renegade Snares”
We could definitely debate the merits of this vs. Roni Size, but we were pretty convinced that everyone hated drum and bass these days in any case. Wait. Is this drum and bass? Jungle? Ok. We just totally blew our cover didn’t we. Just forget you read that.

Basic Channel – “Octagon”
Grudgingly offered kudos are in order on this one. It’s the perfect prestige pick: great minimal techno that no reasonable, healthy person will have ever heard. We’ll spot you a Liquid Liquid white label if you can convince us you wouldn’t rather be listening to “Lovefool”.

Uilab – “St. Elmo’s Fire”
Apparently Stereolab and Sasha Frere-Jones’s pre-New Yorker project, Ui, collaborated on this Brian Eno cover in 1998. It’s not bad, but it’s hard to justify the inclusion of this cover, which sticks pretty tightly to the original, over, say, an original Stereolab song. Our guess is that Schreiber just wanted to give some props to his man SFJ.

2 comments
Email to a friendEmail to a friend TwitterTweet FacebookFacebook Digg thisDigg StumbleUponStumbleUpon
  1. Pitchfork Site Redesign: Mixed Reviews
  2. The 10 Meanest Things Pitchfork Has Said About Weezer
  3. Pre-Order The New Moon Soundtrack for $500

2 Responses

aaa • December 4th, 2008 at 8:45 am

There is no such thing as an "over-abundance of ’70s reggae." All of that shit is classic.

The Pitchfork 500 – In Stores … Now? « Save the Robot – Chris Dahlen • December 5th, 2008 at 8:08 pm

[...] Flavorwire [...]

Post a new comment



Displayed next to your comments.



If you have a website, link to it here.

« Previous Next »
Get your Daily Dose of culture!
    1. What’s on at Flavorpill: Links That Made the Rounds in Our Office
    1. Rate-a-Trailer: The Last Airbender
    1. 2009’s Oddest Book Titles
    1. RIP: The Man Who Gave McSweeney’s Its Name
    1. Daily Dose Pick: Red Riding Trilogy
  • Damien Hirst, Starring in ‘Treasures from the Wreck of the Unbelievable’
    yep, we're entering a lean and hungry time. Much better for artists. like the ea...
    Drusilla • Mon Feb 8 at 4:41am
  • Damien Hirst, Starring in ‘Treasures from the Wreck of the Unbelievable’
    Hirst is clearly a genius. I just wish some of it wound up in the work instead o...
    Sassy • Mon Feb 8 at 2:44am
  • Is “Hallelujah” a Musical Meme?
    Jon Bon Jovi sings it the best, the maturity in his voice adds a realism to the ...
    Shelby • Sun Feb 7 at 11:08pm
  • Damien Hirst, Starring in ‘Treasures from the Wreck of the Unbelievable’
    Hirst is great. You don't have to like him, his art or anything he represents, b...
    Anneke • Sun Feb 7 at 9:48pm
  • Sartorial Showdown: Figure Skater Johnny Weir vs. Lady Gaga
    @Express, no memorable melodies? Did you somehow block out all of 2009 and all o...
    justsayin • Sun Feb 7 at 9:39pm

About Flavorpill

Flavorpill covers cultural events, art, books, music, and world news. Join now.

  • About|
  • Advertise|
  • Jobs|
  • Causes

I want to...

  • Suggest an Event »
  • Send Feedback »
  • Report a Bug »

Our Publications

  • New York »
  • San Francisco »
  • Los Angeles »
  • London »
  • Chicago »
  • Miami »
  • Artkrush »
  • Earplug »
  • Boldtype »
  • Activate »
  • Daily Dose »
Get your Daily Dose of culture!