Jimmy Iovine, Bono, Steve Jobs, and The Edge at the launch of their Product Red line of iPods in 2004.
It’s scary to think that foisting one’s music into millions of iTunes libraries is what it takes to provoke a monocultural level of interest among today’s listening public, but it’s better than the alternative (Kanye-style controversy, looping in Pharrell for Top 40 gold, or both). From U2’s perspective, I can’t tell which is more daunting: scheming up ways to meet their own ridiculous commercial standards, or creatively crafting something you recognize has to be to big to fail. They publicly expressed disappointment when their most recent album, 2009’s No Line on the Horizon, sold about half of what 2004’s How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb did — five million copies worldwide, No. 1 in 30 countries. This time around, U2 gave away 100 times that many copies. Songs of Innocence will still debut at No. 1 when physical copies of the album go on sale October 14, but honestly, none of it really matters when you’re this culturally ubiquitous and wealthy (“The charts are broken,” Bono told TIME). Few would be surprised if they broke their own record for the highest-grossing concert tour in history.
This comes down to U2 seeking relevance — dare I say it, “coolness” — from Apple. This should give you insight into how much time has passed since U2 have been cutting-edge artists, though they’re certainly trying with Songs of Innocence by recruiting Lykke Li as a guest vocalist and “hip” mainstream producers Danger Mouse, Ryan Tedder, and Paul Epworth (in addition to alternative staple Flood). “To be relevant is a lot harder than to be successful,” Bono told The Hollywood Reporter earlier this year, adding that the album’s working title should have been Insecurity.
In a move few seem to remember now, U2 tried to get in on the Super Bowl conversation by releasing a new single, “Invisible” (which does not appear on Songs of Innocence), during the game as a free download with a charity aspect. In the process, the band raised more than $3 million for Bono’s charity RED, thanks to sponsor Bank of America, who donated $1 for every download. But they also managed to shoehorn themselves into a conversation they had nothing to do with, at a time when they were in the news for their Best Original Song Oscar nomination for “Ordinary Love.” They want in on the critically lauded zeitgeist in a way that rock bands, and particularly legacy acts, almost never can be in this era.
What the critics make of Songs of Innocence is mostly unimportant at this initial stage, far more than when Beyoncé released her “visual album” last year for the high price of $16. (To this day, she has kept it off services like Spotify.) Early buzz, including dispatches shared among fans on social media, was key when it came to giving Knowles the biggest opening sales week of her career. How Songs of Innocence plays into U2’s discography will be debated for years to come, but right now, the medium is the message — even more than it was for Radiohead in 2007. U2 figured out their best shot at relevance in 2014: they demanded the masses pay attention, not by making a brilliant album — it’s beautiful and personal yet not terribly memorable — but by inviting everyone to the party.