10 Legendary Lost Albums

Word on the internet this week is that a leaked version of David Bowie’s lost 2001 record Toy has slipped out into the wild and is now doing the round on file-sharing sites. Toy is one of many albums over the course of musical history that for one reason or another got delayed, shelved or otherwise waylaid. There’s often a mythology that grows up around such albums, and although the story can sometimes outweigh the actual music – after all, often albums get canned for a reason — there are some that warrant the attention they attract. Here’s our pick of 10 of music’s best lost records — or the ones that sound like they would be the best, if only we could hear them…

David BowieToy

The late 1990s and early 2000s were a strange period for David Bowie in general — he made a drum’n'bass record, for God’s sake. But things started looking up with 2002′s Heathen, an album that featured a cover of The Pixies’ “Cactus” and got the strongest reviews Bowie had enjoyed in years. Before Heathen, however, came an aborted album called Toy, and while several songs from the Toy sessions ended up on the final album, there’s plenty that didn’t. As such, the record has been something of a Holy Grail for Bowie completists ever since, one of those albums that lots of people have heard about but few have ever heard. Until this week, that is.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] of shiny discs to sell at shows while mostly floating its music on the Net. (That is, at least for post-Professor discs numbers four and five; the third and last set with the former Vortis front man [...]

[...] with Chris Tucker’s film of the same name. We enjoyed The Awl’s response to our legendary lost albums post. We looked at a lot of dirty artwork. And finally, we were jealous of the free bike repair stations [...]

Happy Landings - The Fixx

First time I’ve agreed with someone else’s top ten list! I have been David Bowie fan for a long time. My Best David Bowie Albums Are: 1. Heroes 2. Conversation Piece 3. Can You Hear Me? 4. Under Pressure 5. Sweet Thing 6. Teenage Wildlife 7. Wild Eyed Boy from Freecloud 8. Subterraneans 9. Silly Boy Blue

Oooh really? I am all for Betty Davis. I'll have to investigate this.

Betty Davis's Is It Love or Desire is brilliant. As far as I'm aware, hardly anyone even knew it was missing, and then all of a sudden it emerged in the last couple of years. A forgotten album from a forgotten artist.

what no q-tip's Kamal the Abstract? Somebody dropped the ball.

The The - Pornography of Despair and Gun Sluts Kraftwerk - Technopop

The Clipse's first album, Exclusive Audio Footage, was never released for those very same "can't hear a single" reasons mentioned above. Finally got to hear it and while some is definitely unformed, some of it is very, very good - it's the Neptunes after all! They even made a video for The Funeral - check it out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P8NnDbfd4yc

R&B singer Jon B had a side project called Jack Herrera, a live soul band. Incredible departure from his mainstream R&B work. Completed an entire album called Retro Futuristo (which can be easily located with a little Googling). But due to label politics, the whole thing got scrapped and the group eventually disbanded. It's a shame because it was such a solid album. Featured high profile guest appearances by will.i.am of Black Eyed Peas and Black Thought of The Roots.

SELF's breakout album "Ornament and Crime" was caught in the shuffle when Dreamworks Records folded into DGC into Universal (not sure of the actual order there). Considering the dude played with Beck and a couple pop stars at the same time he produced #1s for White Tie Affair and Hellogoodbye, I think it's high time people hear brilliant radio-ready songs like "Emotional" and "Insecure Sober" and "The Pounding Truth". Million dollar recording budget in full effect.

Stuff Up the Cracks by Pavement Music that defined the early 90s and set the table for indie rock. Four of their best songs appeared on it: Kentucky Cocktail, Haunt You Down, Circa 1762, and the Silver Jews great one -- Secret Knowledge of Backroads. Should have been released, but wasn't until being included on the Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain (L.A.'s Desert Origins) reissue.

Agree 100% with Ben (above) RE: J-Live

1) The The - Pornography of Despair 2) The Units - BOTH their 2nd & 3rd records (both produced by Bill Nelson) 3) PiL - 4th lp (bootlegged as Commercial Zone)

What about Marvin Gaye, Vulnerable?

Although released, but not fully, J Lives debut album should be on here.

Ummmm the R. Kelly & Jay-Z album anyone?

I would add to this list Captain Beefheart's 1976 "Bat Chain Puller," recorded for Frank Zappa and never released. Most of the songs ended up on "Shiny Beast" a couple of years later, but the performances aren't quite as good as the earlier ones. It's not hard to find bootlegs.

Interesting piece, but there are many, many more. One lost album I would love to hear is the one Seal recorded between Human Being (1998) and Seal IV (2003) with Malcolm McLaren as producer. After three albums with Trevor Horn, Seal felt that people were giving Horn too much credit for the Seal sound, and that he should do an album without him, showcasing his grittier side. God knows what he and McLaren got up to in the endless sessions that followed, but eventually Seal chickened out, binned the lot and returned to Trevor Horn for the disappointingly samey Seal IV.

@John: OH MAN TAPEWORM. My college roomate was obsessed with that band one day starting. That, and Dave Navarro's "Spread".

Would be cool to see "The Greatest Bands Never". You could start the list with Tapeworm. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tapeworm_(band)

THE BLACK ALBUM is SO GOOD. SO, so, so good.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] with Chris Tucker’s film of the same name. We enjoyed The Awl’s response to our legendary lost albums post. We looked at a lot of dirty artwork. And finally, we were jealous of the free bike repair stations [...]

  2. [...] of shiny discs to sell at shows while mostly floating its music on the Net. (That is, at least for post-Professor discs numbers four and five; the third and last set with the former Vortis front man [...]