10 Great Books about Music by Female Writers

Earlier this week the folk over at Pitchfork published a collection of their favorite music books. It’s a pretty comprehensive list, encompassing everything from Mötley Crüe’s tragicomic memoir The Dirt to Jon Savage’s erudite punk tome England’s Dreaming. We couldn’t help noticing, however, that of the 60 books on show, precisely one was written solely by a woman (along with a couple where there’s a female co-author, and one anthology of women writers). We’re not suggesting that Pitchfork has gone out of its way to exclude women — the fact is that, sadly, like much of the music industry, music criticism remains very much a boys’ club. That doesn’t mean, however, that they’re entirely blameless. Here are ten great books about music written by women that really should have at least merited consideration.

Kristin Hersh, Rat Girl

Here at Flavorpill, we heart Kristin Hersh (especially when she tweets nice things about us). We also loved her 2010 memoir Rat Girl, which was based on the diaries she kept during a particularly tumultuous period of her life — specifically, late 1985 and early 1986, when Throwing Muses’ career started to take off, but Hersh herself was diagnosed with bipolar disorder and also gave birth to her first child. Her writing is full of the dramatic energy that characterizes her songwriting, but it’s also funny and self-effacing. Rat Girl does a beautiful job of capturing the runaway train of adolescence, the feeling that you don’t know where you’re going, but you can’t stay where you are.

Filed Under:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] straight-up list with no commentary and some books I do not think are very good. Flavorwire’s ten great books about music by female writers does a more thorough job, and includes many of the books on my own list (and one I hated). Their [...]

[...] This week, Pitchfork compiled a list of their favorite books about music. Noting that the authors on said list were overwhelmingly male, Tom Hawking assembled a list in response for Flavorwire. [...]

Snarky comments are avoiding the fact that it's great to get a top 10 female writers list, as Tom said in a still male dominated industry. Kudos to the Girrls I say.

The Importance of Music to Girls by Lavinia Greenlaw just brilliant.

@Tom - Yes, I agree, you are a joke. @Andy B(alless) - ANY TIME I'LL MEET YOU. WELL??!! Send me your address Mary -Boy. And yes, indeed, as your mother and half the world already knows, you are an asshole.

"Out of the Vinyl Deeps," by Ellen Willis, a pioneering female music writer.

Sad to see Jen Trynin's "Everything I'm Cracked Up to Be: A Rock and Roll Fairy Tale" missing from this list.

you missed babes in toylands book!

I also loved some of the wives of rock star books like Cynthia Lennon, Deborah Curtis, Angela Bowie, Pamela Des Barres - Marianne Faithfull's - Faithfull being the stand out best!

Drugs are Nice by Lisa Crystal Carver - one of the best books of all time (but also by a woman and about music) also Roxon's Rock Encyclopedia? Also Be My Baby by Ronnie Spector!

@Chris Roberts: Glad to hear you and Chom-pers have some giggles. When I hang out with jesus, neil gaiman, tori amos and tori spelling, we ALL laugh EQUALLY. so.

I have no end of entertainment when readers just can't read a story online and not hit the 'keyboard bravado' button and bash it out. Comments sections have ruined net journalism, degenerating debate to that whole fan boy culture of sci-fi fans spitting on about George Lucas raping their childhood or whatever. Nothing is written in an 'in my opnion' vain, it's just "I am holier than thou and my opinion wipes the floor with your pitiful crud". Ah well, if I wasn't checking back here to see that dip shit Chris Roberts snooty literary snob crud backlash, i'd invite him to meet me on my block where we could see if his fight is bigger than his inflated ego and boorish mouth. But alas I'll avoid the comments section from now on, but I will miss the trolls like our friend Chris here (frat boy comment was gold. Oh dear oh dear...). Tom, love you're work and enjoying the lists, keep them coming and screw what others say. Oh dammit, I just contradicted myself hanging shit on our friend Chris while slamming keyboard bravado! I'm such as asshole!

Haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahahahahahahahahaha "I had Noam Chomsky in tears..." Thanks for making my day, Chris. That's seriously the best thing I've read in absolutely ages. Now, if you'll excuse me, the pigs are coming in to land.

@Tom Hawking - If someone posts a contrary view, that makes him/her a troll. How laughable is that mindset. But doesn't a troll typically use profanity? That makes you one Tommy Boy with your fucked balls, TMI bye the bye, and your reaction is straight-up frat style as in boorish and rather beyond yourself. Recognize your severely limited debating skills. I had Noam Chomsky in tears, so really, what shot do you have? I'll answer that: none.

@Chris Roberts - your post is so wrong-headed that it's hard to know where to start. So a band needs to chart an album to have a story? (That's the Velvet Underground fucked, then.) And musicians need to take drugs to be interesting? Really? I'm also not sure what's with your repeated use of the word "frat" - as far as I'm aware, the only time fraternities get a mention is when Kristin dodges a couple of frat dickheads at a bar. If you think being at college constitutes a frat party, then... Aw, fuck, I'm feeding the trolls again, aren't I? Balls.

(F)Rat Girl is a non-stop banal trip that is in need of some acid or anything to kick start this exaggerated frat party. The Throwing Muses never charted an album in the U.S., so where's the story? New Wave artists ruled in the mid-eighties. Being in a band, being a teenager, doesn't mean you have to write about your state of being, it's been told and sold.

@Snarky: "Would this post exist if people weren’t all gaga for ‘Just Kids’?" Yes. Yes, it would.

Also, suggest "I'm In The Band: Backstage Notes From The Chick In White Zombie" by Sean Yseult

The original title of this post was, "Another list with 'Just Kids'" ...am I rite? I kid but would this post exist if people weren't all gaga for 'Just Kids'?

Not only does Kristin Hersh have a fantastic voice, she has great taste in cover artists. That's Beto Hernandez (of Love and Rockets fame) who also did the cover and liner notes for Limbo and its singles.

@Abby - Ah, I haven't read that yet. People keep recommending it to me, though.

A Visit from the Goon Squad, by Jennifer Egan.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] straight-up list with no commentary and some books I do not think are very good. Flavorwire’s ten great books about music by female writers does a more thorough job, and includes many of the books on my own list (and one I hated). Their [...]

  2. [...] This week, Pitchfork compiled a list of their favorite books about music. Noting that the authors on said list were overwhelmingly male, Tom Hawking assembled a list in response for Flavorwire. [...]